First thing is, at that budget there are no guarantee's regarding reliablity. Even the most reliable car on paper can become a money pit after 10-15 years of neglect.
However, to minimise your risk, look for something mechanically simple and straightforward which means naturally aspirated (no turbo) petrol engine and a manual gearbox. Avoid diesel as even at this age they were getting very complicated so any problems are likely to be both major in nature and very expensive to rectify.
Out of the cars you have mentioned (without having seen them), the two Toyota's would be the best bet. I would not consider the Renault (despite being a 1.6 petrol) as that model had some gimicky stuff like a card instead of a key, stuff which as the car gets older is more likely to go wrong. The Mazda, if it was a petrol, would be a great choice, but as a diesel (even though this model used the Mondeo TDCI engine as opposed to Mazda's own notoriously unreliable unit in later models), i just wouldn't chance it.
At this price point, a private sale is probably going to be a better bet than a trader, preferably from someone who has owned the car for some years. Also, use the online website for checking the MOT history, which will give you an idea how well the car has been maintained and looked after, www.gov.uk/check-mot-history
Other cars to consider would be, in no particular order:
Toyota Corolla and Verso,
Honda Civic and Accord,
Ford Focus, C-Max and Mondeo
Mazda 3 and 6
Kia Cerato, Cee'd, Carens, Mentor and Magentis
Hyundai Accent, i30, Elantra, Matrix and Sonata
If you could manage with a smaller car this list could also include:
Toyota Yaris
Honda Jazz
Ford Fusion or Fiesta
Mazda 2
Suzuki Swift, Ignis and SX4
Kia Rio
Hyundai Getz and i20
If you let us know where you are in the country, and what the smallest size of car you need, i'd be happy to have a look online at possible cars for you.
Edited by badbusdriver on 05/12/2018 at 08:45
|