M-way closures - Ed V

The M25 and others are closed quite frequently due to an accident. Recently, the section west of Chertsey was closed for 6 or 7 hours, causing huge delays to tens of thousands of people. If the cause of the accident (is it not quite difficult to crash on a road carrying traffc only in one direction with no bends?) was made public, what then?

Those who missed family holiday flights from Heathrow / Gatwick, job interviews, other commercial deadlines, wasted fuel, those on hourly charge out rates etc, could sue for damages.

Why is this not done by those so inconvenienced. Is it 'not British'?

Just imagine if rail brought in trains carrying 1,000 half a day late several times a week!! All hell would break out. Why not with motorway accidents? The cost to UK plc must be horrendous.

M-way closures - NARU

It does seem perverse that so much effort/inconvenience is caused by trying to get to the root cause of the crash, but then ... nothing.

Train and airplane drivers undergo regular top-up training, where the results of previous crashes are used to improve their skills.

But a car driver can pass their test at 17, and never have to have a day of top-up training - ever! As a consequence we can have someone who makes errors day in, day out. Most of the time they get away with it. But if the worst happens, and someone dies, they can lose their licence/face a heavy fine/go to prison.

We need to make up our mind whether we want to reduce road deaths (and serious injuries) or not. Current evidence suggests we're not.

Instead we have the worst of both worlds - lots of disruption after a crash whilst the root cause is investigated, but no feedback cycle to reduce it happening again.

Edited by Marlot on 26/08/2013 at 08:17

M-way closures - Bromptonaut

Closures are for either or both of accident investigation and repairs to carriageway and/or barriers.

It's clearly not at all difficult to crash on an M/way mixing cars with heavy trucks etc and drivers who lose concentration, drop off or whatever. My last near miss was a delaminating tyre on an HGV taking a fair chunk of mud spray flap with it as it exited.

Modern A&E technique involves stabilising the casualty on site rather than the 'scoop and scarper' of years gone by.

Fifty years ago the populace accepted sudden death. Wars and work in factories and mines meant people took sudden widowhood as a fact of life. They were also used to seeing death and injury for same reasons. Now we all want somebody held accountable at both criminal and civil law and that requires the authorities to fully investigate accidents involving death or life changing injury.

Even allowing public to filter past might invite a claim for 'trauma' through seeing a mangled victim.

The same thing happens on the railway too. Lost count of the hours I've kicked my heels at Euston or been diverted via St Pancras because of a person hit by a train - usually suicide.

The fact of a major road closure is disseminated via the overhead gantries over long distances. A recent closure of the A43 between M1 and M40 was being advised just after Sheffield giving drivers plenty of time to locate/use alternatives - of which there are several. The M25 is different as it lacks so many alternatives but there are possibilities.

Edited by Bromptonaut on 26/08/2013 at 09:59

M-way closures - gordonbennet

Very good post Bromp.

Its the so long as it doesn't affect me attitude at play, which would immediately change if the victim was known/related.

Any motorway victim is somebody's loved one, each and every one deserves to have the circumstances of their untimely death or massive life changing injuries investigated fully, not a 5 minute job.

However i can only agree with comments about appalling and getting worse driving standards in all vehicle classes, taking away peoples responsibilities and making vehicles easie/dumber to drive quickly isn't making the situation better...indeed the lorry test is being further dumbed down and if anyone can explain to me why (without the cheap driver which arn't in the long term argument) i'd be pleased to hear why...the car test is so outdated, theory not competence biased, as to be verging on the ridiculous.

M-way closures - alastairq

.the car test is so outdated, theory not competence biased, as to be verging on the ridiculous.

In what way is a driving assessment, over a period of time, in whatever traffic situations arise, at that time, outdated?

I think it is forgotten that the cat B test is a basic assessment of competence.

Insuring that all novice drivers are at least starting out their driving lives from a common baseline of expertise

I seriously doubt that many of those who contribute on this forum would actually meet the required standards of a driving test, today. Regardless of how many years they have 'held' their licence...or how many miles they cover each year. [I prefer to use 'time behind the wheel' rather than 'mileage' to place a value on experience.]

In the above..before the outrage appears...consider the sheer number of 'driving faults' you each display,every time you get behind a steering wheel, or handlebars?

What is forgetten with regards to training, and assessment of competence..is despite the candidate meeting the required standards on the day, it is then up to that individual to maintain, and improve, on the standards attained.

This, most do not do, in any way, shape or form....and not just with driving, either.

Which is why we get doctors, airplane pilots, ships' officers, lawyers, plumbers, et al, getting it wrong all too frrequently.

What is lacking...amongst those who 'think' they are so-called 'good' drivers is..tolerance of others. Tolerance of varying degrees of skill & awareness.

If anybody seriously thinks things need changing...and have sound ideas..go and join the Driving Standards Agency..where the ideas can be put to good use.

As for 'compensation' for lost time?

The people who should be sued for compensation in those circumstances, are those who are involved, or have been deemed to have been responsible, for the incident.

Not the Agencies who are merely involved with clearing up the mess.

Or..should we have, on the M25, a fleet of bulldozers ready to leap into action at the first mishap, and bulldoze the wreckage, and gore, off the motorway..so's all you kind folk can get to your interviews on time?

Snotmifault is an excuse I for one don't swallow.

M-way closures - RT
I think it is forgotten that the cat B test is a basic assessment of competence.

Yes - but that's all many drivers achieve - there is no follow up.

I'd like to see a mandatory test, roughly equal to the Advanced Driving Test, that MUST be passed within 5 years of passing the basic B test, with follow-up tests every 5 years.

Oh no, that won't work as about 50-60% of current drivers would be banned from driving as they'd be incapable of passing an advanced level test - but it would solve the road congestion issues!

M-way closures - NARU
I'd like to see a mandatory test, roughly equal to the Advanced Driving Test, that MUST be passed within 5 years of passing the basic B test, with follow-up tests every 5 years.

Oh no, that won't work as about 50-60% of current drivers would be banned from driving as they'd be incapable of passing an advanced level test - but it would solve the road congestion issues!

That would work for me.

A half-way house of some additional training but no requirement to pass a test might be more acceptable. But it all needs to start with people wanting to cut road crashes. And I don't see that demand.

M-way closures - Andrew-T

Any motorway victim is somebody's loved one, each and every one deserves to have the circumstances of their untimely death or massive life changing injuries investigated fully, not a 5 minute job.

Of course, but I think the balance between the essentials of dealing with the injured, investigating possible causes, and reopening the road to traffic has tipped away from the uninvolved public. The police seem much keener to simply close a road - presumably hoping that will save time in the end - than to manage the situation on the spot, as it were, without disrupting traffic. [ I think the French have done this for longer than we have ]. I don't agree that the needs of those involved take precedence over the rest of us without limit.

The balance seems to have shifted too far in favour of officials, who sometimes appear to overexploit their authority.

M-way closures - RT

There was a time when the police had sufficient manpower to allocate resources to managing the traffic flow as well as the incident itself - but those times are long gone with peripheral duties handed over to Highway Agency who are only interested in road condition reinstatement.

M-way closures - Ben 10

But those times are long gone.

Rubbish. I've attended numerous RTA/Cs during my 32 year career, and the police flood the scene when they don't meed to. They can have the minimum number of crew to investigate, but the vast majority of plods that turn up are there to gawp. The surplus need to roll back and DEAL with managing the traffic that gridlocks the roundabouts and junctions along diversion routes.

M-way closures - Sofa Spud

QUOTE:...""appalling and getting worse driving standards in all vehicle classes, taking away peoples responsibilities and making vehicles easie/dumber to drive quickly isn't making the situation better...""

I don't think driving standards are any worse than they used to be, say, 30 years ago. There's more traffic on the roads, so if the proportion of bad driving is the same, we see more of it. Cars and motorbikes are faster and more powerful than they used to be, so bad drivers can be doing their bad driving at considerably higher speed than in the past.

M-way closures - Smileyman

it's the police to blame, they act as if they are beyind reproach and all other people and their needs are unimportant.

I know they have a job to do, and after loosing a relative in a car crash I saw the results of their very detailed investigation at the inquest, however they never 'seem' to give any consideration to the other victims of the event - the delayed innocent motorists. The cost to these people and the wider community is hidden, (both financial and in sheer & utter frustration) certainly off the police balance sheet and perhaps this is one way to get them to act more quickly to get the traffic moving. A second way would be for them to state the length of time the traffic was delayed and to justify with detail this time, perhaps after a few incidents a trend will emerge and this will educate them in areas of improvement.

Oh, be careful, they might suggest you are disrupting them in evidence gathering, I'm sure it's a criminal offence.

M-way closures - RT

it's the police to blame, they act as if they are beyind reproach and all other people and their needs are unimportant.

I imagine once you've scraped body parts together a few times, that by being very hardened is the only way to get through it professionally - which probably applies to paramedics and fire/rescue crews as well as police.

Remember there's no such thing as a Road Traffic Accident (RTA) - they're all Road Traffic Collisions (RTC) because someone is always at fault.

M-way closures - galileo

M62 closed from 6 am for 11 hours yesterday due to a truck overturning, 2 fatalities in the car it fell onto.

Result, chaos over much of West Yorkshire, some motorists stuck for 7 hours.

Police investigation reportedly complete at 2 pm, then removed vehicles, then inspcted carriageway, finally opened at 5 pm.

A number of police forces have laser scene recording gadgets, I believe, which are claimed to save time in measuring/photographing scenes, I don't know if WY have such devices.

M-way closures - Bobbin Threadbare

Some time back the M6 was shut because there was a man on a footbridge threatening to throw himself off. They negotiated with him for many hours. Mr B was stuck in it; people were stranded for hours, and having picnics on the motorway. Some people even played catch and had a stroll. He recalls speaking to several parties of people on their way to L'pool/Manc airports, who completely missed their flights. He himself missed a test for his PCV/D1 licence, at considerable cost and inconvenience to his employers.

The police did charge the man on the bridge - some sort of time-wasting misdemeanour.

M-way closures - Collos25

Its all part of life its what makes it interesting ,no appointment is more important than a human life.

M-way closures - RT

In the olden days, when the motorways were first built and no speed limits applied, it was simple for one of the traffic officers to direct traffic over the grass central reservation and back to the previous junction to find an alternative route.

In this day and age of satnavs, I doubt that many drivers could work out where they were on a map never mind plan an alternative.

M-way closures - Andrew-T

.... no appointment is more important than a human life.

Agreed, but a thousand appointments, booked flights, etc.- possibly even attendance at an inquest?

M-way closures - Ben 10

Accident: an undesirable or unfortunate happening that occurs unintentionally and usually results in harm, injury, damage, or loss; casualty; mishap: automobile accidents.

Collision: the act of colliding

I've always used the term RTA. The fashionable useage is RTC. To be different. The explanation for accident is self explanatary, and more pertenant. So there is such a thing. Unless it's intentional which the hundreds of RTAs I've attended haven't been.

M-way closures - Andrew-T

A second way would be for them to state the length of time the traffic was delayed and to justify with detail this time, perhaps after a few incidents a trend will emerge and this will educate them in areas of improvement..

Delays to travel on the railways result in crippling fines, in the hope that they may be contained. I don't see why the road system is different in principle?

M-way closures - sandy56
Driving on UK roads has become a nightmare.
I am very lucky in that I don't drive much on our roads anymore.
I have found that certain employers are very proactive in ensuring their staff have regular annual driving reviews by an expert driver. The test drivers were empowered to stop you driving on company business. The rules for safe driving was- guess what- the Highway Code.

I wonder how many of our professional drivers of large heavy vehicles have annual reviews?
How many are required to do a thorough check of their vehicle every time they use it, and how may are banned from using a mobile phone whilst the vehicle is moving.
The solution to the known problems are available, it is just that nobody is using them and the Government would rather give our road taxes to the great unwashed than use it to build a proper road network.
M-way closures - dan86

All lgv psv drivers javr to do 35 hours compulsery training over a 5 year period under new EU law called the driver cpc. It doesn't just cover driving but all aspects of the jobs that they do including first aid. No car driver is forced by law to do anything like that.

M-way closures - Andrew-T
... the Government would rather give our road taxes to the great unwashed than use it to build a proper road network.

I'm not sure what you see as a "proper road network". If you mean improving our two-lane A-roads, perhaps by adding cycle lanes, OK. If you mean several more motorways, not so. They carve up what little space is left in our densely-inhabited areas, adding uncrossable and hazardous new boundaries, creating traffic and overloading the established network where they connect with it.

The real problem with M-way closures is that when one happens there is no escape. Give me an A-road and a decent atlas ....

M-way closures - Bromptonaut


Delays to travel on the railways result in crippling fines, in the hope that they may be contained. I don't see why the road system is different in principle?

The railway system is governed by complex contracts between Network Rail and the various passenger and freight train companies operating over particular sections of track.

If a London Midland train fails on the down fast line at 17:30 it's going to hold up a whole string of Virgin trains behind.

If however its a suicide or a tresspasser everything stops on all our lines but no penalties ensue.

That seems the nearest analogy to RTA/C.

M-way closures - Avant

"The railway system is governed by complex contracts between Network Rail and the various passenger and freight train companies operating over particular sections of track."

Off-topic but thank you, Bromptonaut, for summing up in a single sentence the cause of the railways' current malaise (the work of the Major government in the early 1990s).

M-way closures - Smileyman

I don't see why it should be a malaise ..... airports and sea ports are used by carriers of different companies, ATC controls the aircraft in flight (must be more complex since it is goverened by international agreements and then there is the military with their needs to consider too). The Swiss trains run on time, and there also have different companies operating services as well as internattional services too.

UK roads need to be better managed so that delays are reduced - even opening one lane is better than creating a car park.