I sold my BMW and it broke down on the new owner. What's the likelihood of being sued?

I sold my car to a really nice guy who drove it round the block. I suggested going further to "open it up a bit" and he went a little more, but not far. He offered me a cheque, slightly below the asking price, which I agreed to but I would not release the car until cleared. I picked him up from the train station the following Saturday and he took the car. Everyone was happy! Then I received a voicemail message. The first, which horrified me, said that he'd broken down on the motorway. In subsequent messages he implied suing me, calling the police, taking legal action and said that the car was not as described. I felt verbal contact was not the best way forward so did not reply.

I wrote to him explaining just that and asked the nature of the fault. On returning from work I had a recorded letter saying "the engine failed catastrophically at speed on the M27" further stating the head gasket failed. Although, at first, I wanted to help, he said he has initiated court proceedings so I don't know what is best. He paid £800 and I know I wouldn't be happy either, but I don't know whether it was the car's fault or what he meant by "at speed". How do I stand legally?

Asked on 10 September 2010 by thedebs53

Answered by Lucy
If you are a private seller then he is pretty much on his own and he has no claim against you. It is "buyer beware" and he does not have a chance in court. The police won't be interested. We have had a number of reports of similar occurrences which have scam-like characteristics and I would be interested in hearing how this progresses.
Similar questions
I advertised my Alvis 12/50 on EBay and a multi-millionaire said he wanted my car so we agreed on £36,000, so I finished the auction early on 26-10-14, he was difficult to contact after sale and ended...
My son bought a BMW 1 Series this week from a private seller for £2500. He has had it five days and only driven it 25 miles. Yesterday, it failed to start. It would turn over but not fire up. When we got...
I have just privately bought an Audi A4. One reason for buying was service book check-boxes ticked and stamped by main dealer, including toothed belt at 50,000 miles. Upon checking with main dealer they...
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 10% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ10 to save on an ALA policy

See offer