Air-con failure after purchase - is it covered by the warranty?

In March, I bought a low-mileage (10,000) 2013 Porsche Boxster from a Porsche dealer, including - what I thought was - a rock-solid two year warranty. Initially, I didn't use the air-con (to save fuel) but when I tried it for the first time on a wet day - on 10 June - I realised that the air-con wasn't working at all. On my return home on 14 June, I reported the problem to both the supplying Porsche dealership and also my local Porsche service centre. I booked the car in as soon as possible for the work to be done, on June 27 - 28, on the assumption that a repair would would be fully covered by the warranty. I was then told that there was stone damage to one of the condensers which had disabled the air-con. I had no option but to pay the bill, just over £700. My perception is that I was sold a car without working air-con. The service dealer regards this as ‘external damage’ and therefore not covered by the warranty. The salesman was sympathetic but referred to the comprehensive pre-delivery check that the car had passed just before I bought it in March. As a gesture of goodwill, he has offered to pay 50 per cent of the bill but that still leaves me £350 out of pocket. Am I likely to be able to recover my loss or is this the best I can hope for?

Asked on 2 July 2017 by Peter McDonald

Answered by Honest John
Stone damage is the same as any kind of damage to the car. Not warranted. Had you used the a/c from day one you'd have found out if it was working then or not. As it is, you have no proof that a stone did not damage the condenser during your tenure of the car. It's actually stupid not to use a/c. Doesn't affect fuel economy and if you don't use it it doesn't self-lubricate and is prone to lose its refrigerant anyway.
Similar questions
I have two Nissan Qashqai, both under 10000 miles, just out of warranty and both with broken air con. Nissan is graciously offering 75 per cent contribution towards the parts. But I'm still left with a...
We have a two year old SEAT Ibiza which needed an air conditioning re-gas, costing £70 as it wasn't covered by warranty. Nine months down the line it has failed again. By my reckoning, it has a leak which...
I collected my new Ford Mondeo from the dealer at the beginning of July. I glanced over the vehicle before collection and it appeared to be okay. The following day, I noted that the rear bumper was actually...
Related models
All-new Boxster is lighter and more economical. Returns a claimed 36mpg. Good looking redesigned interior. Even better to drive than before.
 

Value my car