Buying an AWD SUV - what would you recommend?

I'm in a position where I need to replace my Suzuki Grand Vitara with a similar SUV or 4x4. I need something which can seat five adults, has 4x4 or AWD capability for towing and which will enable me to tow 1400kg on a post 97 license as I passed my test in 2005. I have a strong preference for a manual gear box and a spare wheel rather than an inflation kit. My daily travel is a 10 minute trip to the station, would I be better of with a petrol for this? What would you recommend and are there any vehicles I should avoid?

Asked on 29 December 2016 by pcroser

Answered by Honest John
Absolutely has to be petrol for this sort of use. Cheapest is a Dacia Duster 1.2 TCe 4x4: www.honestjohn.co.uk/road-tests/dacia/dacia-duster.../. You will see from my test of the Duster that the gearing is good for towing, with a relatively low 1st and 2nd and generally low gearing (which is why it goes better than a Qashqai 1.2-litre TCe, but uses more fuel).
Similar questions
My 15-year-old Mercedes E-Class estate finally got scrapped last year, so I treated myself to an E63 AMG estate. I love the car and I can still get masses of stuff inside and on the roof, but I can't legally...
I cover about 10,000 miles per year, mostly journeys of 50+ miles. I need a 4x4 to negotiate muddy/slippery tracks and to tow a trailer. I'm looking at the 2007 diesel Honda CR-V with 70,000 recorded miles...
I have a limited budget of £4000 and am looking for a reliable and economical 4x4 vehicle to tow a single horse trailer (need 1500kg kerb weight).
Related models
Great value for money. Spacious and practical cabin. Available with all-wheel drive for less than £12,000. 5 Stars for Duster 125 TCe 4WD.
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car