Which hothatch is best?

Thirty five years ago I owned a lovely Golf GTI Mk 1, I would like to experience again the thrill of owning and driving a small, grippy and nippy car in the form of a new five-door performance hatch.

I cover around 11,000 miles a year comprising mainly shortish (around 15 miles) local journeys plus some wider UK travel and continental motorway slogs involving drives of 500 miles every six months or so. My shortlist includes the latest Golf GTI, Audi S1 and Ford Focus ST2. I am disinclined to go for diesel due to the fact that shortish journeys will make up the bulk of my driving. What do you think?

Asked on 28 April 2016 by Steve Francis

Answered by Honest John
The best is the Fiesta ST, but only three-doors. However, you can get a 5 door Audi S1, even though there's very little room in the back: www.honestjohn.co.uk/road-tests/audi/audi-s1-2014-.../ A SEAT Leon Cupra 280 is better value and faster than a Golf GTI: www.honestjohn.co.uk/road-tests/seat/seat-leon-st-.../ Early Focus STs had a dodgy diff: www.honestjohn.co.uk/road-tests/ford/ford-focus-st.../
Similar questions
I recently bought my 80 year old petrolhead father a Ford Focus RS. In fact my idea was to let him drive it for a few weeks, that was on 3 September and I've not had it back since! He is now emailing...
My wife is considering replacing her 2002 Toyota Corolla T sport, which has provided outstandingly reliable and fun motoring from new. She only does 5000 miles a year and prefers the style and flexibility...
I currently have a Renault Kadjar 1.6 dCi. I like the car, but the engine feels sluggish compared to the same engine I had in my previous Nissan Qashqai. I want to replace the Renault as I no longer need...
Related models
Comes in two power outputs of 220PS GTI and GTI Performance with 230PS. Has larger brake discs and a front limited-slip differential. A great all round hot hatch.
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car