Which SUV is best for family life?

I am looking to replace our 2006 Saab 93 estate, your advice on an SUV style vehicle as a replacement would be appreciated? Our budget is up to £14,000 for a car of 3 years/ 30,000 miles (inc P/x if there is much value in the Saab).

Our requirements are for a car allowing me to do motorway driving for work (circa 20,000 a year), diesel and fuel economy (50mpg). As a second car it would also have to be capable of two children and all that they involved at weekends hence sensible rear legroom.

I am currently looking at the BMW X1 and Nissan Qashqai but open to your suggestions for the best / most suitable in the market sector. Due to family events safety is a key priority and hence five star NCAP.

I am a regular reader and appreciate you professional and practical advice, many thank.

Asked on 7 April 2016 by JGreen81

Answered by Honest John
If it's a Qashqai it has to be the 1.6dCi 130, not the 1.5dCi. Much more modern engine that has been virtually trouble-free for nearly six years now. Old model X1 not so good. Worries about timing chains and 20,000 mile oil changes on BMW 2.0 diesel engines. Smaller, a KIA cee'd or Hyundai i30 1.6CRDI might do the job, and if you can find one within budget a Honda Civic Sport Tourer 1.6iDTEC is a 60mpg car.
Similar questions
We're looking for a SUV to cater for our new family. The car will have to take a child’s seat and pram. We've narrowed it down to the Nissan Qashqai 1.6 CVT Acenta Premium, which seemed oddly cramped inside,...
Having had Volkswagens and Audis before, we are looking to change our Ford S-Max for something a little more rewarding to drive with a good solid feel. It’s been a good car, great for space and with kids...
Have been looking for a new car to cover around 20k miles a year and my priorities are refinement and long distance comfort - personal purchase rather than via my company. Have been impressed by both the...
Related models
Improved interior over previous Qashqai. Very smooth and quiet ride. High torque 1.3-litre petrol engines from 2019 a vast improvement.

Ask Honest John

Value my car