What to replace a Golf with?

Looking for a car to replace an S-reg Golf GTD TD and am totally confused by too many choices in a smaller car. I've been looking at Fiat 500, Volkswagen Up, Nissan Micra, Honda Jazz, Suzuki Grand Vitara. I would like to have sat nav, climate control, petrol engine, good mileage per gallon, cheap to run and service, some get up and go on motorway, safety features. Big things in a small package. Prefer hatchback to saloon as need to transport large dog from time to time. Use is mainly on a Scottish island but sometimes travel to mainland on motorways for journeys to Manchester area.

Asked on 30 November 2015 by wits end

Answered by Honest John
The new Vitara S 1.4T promises a lot. 4WD, 140PS 1.4 Turbo engine. 127g/km CO2. 50mpg. But £21,500. FIAT 500 are cute and have by far the best front seats of any small car, but aren't the best handling small cars unless you go for the Abarth on 16-inch (not 17-inch) wheels. MINIs are lots of fun, even the new MINI One. Honda Jazz are practical with the roomiest, most versatile interior of any small car. In UK CVT7 spec they are economical, but slow. Try a MINI One.
Similar questions
We're looking for a replacement for a 2004 1.2 Skoda Fabia. The car will do approximately 40 miles a day, 70% of which is on dual carriageway which may be sufficient to make a diesel a more economical...
I am looking at a Sept 11 ,61 plate Citroen C3 1,6 automatic exclusive at £8995 from main dealer. Are you happy with this automatic? Test drive was good. However I hired by chance a Hyundai 130 1.4 manual...
My car was recently written off in an accident where someone went into the back of me. My car was a 2002 Vauxhall Corsa Elegance 1.2. If my budget was around £2500-£3000 for a replacement, what would you...
Related models
New engines including 1.2 and 1.5-litre three-cylinder and 2.0 litre. More refined and better steering feel plus much more fun to drive than previous MINI.
Very good to drive and comfortable. Lots of interior space. Five star Euro NCAP rating. Relatively economical. Excellent 1.0 BoosterJet engines.

Ask Honest John

Value my car