Should I replace my 2002 Audi A4 with an SUV?

I have run a 2002 Audi A4 SE130 TDI from new. It's reliable and cost efficient. However the joints are getting creaky (mine and my wife's, not the car's) and we want something more upright and comfortable with higher seats. Should we go down the SUV path? I've tested a few, but am not yet convinced. We are also considering starting to tow a caravan, so the A4 isn't much good for that either - can you recommend a few vehicles to look at or should I wait for the Q3 next year?

Asked on 6 July 2010 by gord

Answered by Honest John

I got 55.1mpg from the new Mitsubushi ASX, which I find fantastic and previously unheard of for an SUV. It has the world's first diesel engine with variable valve timing, so that and "Intelligent Mobility" must be responsible. Test at: www.honestjohn.co.uk/road-tests/mitsubishi/mitsubi...x HJ

Tags: fuel economy towing suvs high seating position

Similar questions

Which economical SUV or saloon for towing and seating comfort?

Next summer I intend to trade in my three-year-old SEAT Altea XL Sport for a new or nearly new car. The car needs to able to tow a 1100kg caravan, be economical, and capable of 45 miles per gallon solo....

I want a car that has a spacious boot, good fuel economy and is cheap to insure/tax?

What car is best for me? I like a high driving position, boot space for camping, good fuel economy, ideally some bodywork protection/trims, good all-round driving visibility, cheap to insure/tax.

What is your opinion on the Dacia Duster?

We currently own a Hyundai Matrix automatic which is two and a half years old with 19,000 miles. Since we both appreciate relatively high seating we thought this was an appropriate vehicle for us. Unfortunately...

Related models