Buying a used car - petrol or diesel?

I'm looking for a five year old car, with a budget of £9000. I'm inclined toward a diesel due to the low-down torque and economy, but also think that a petrol might be cheaper in the long run.

The car must be reliable though, with minimal future repair costs and I'll be covering 10,000 miles a year. What do you suggest I buy?

Asked on 6 April 2015 by Mr L. Smith

Answered by Honest John
Five year old diesels are bad buys because, while they can be cheap to run for the first few years under warranty, they are expensive once they surpass 60,000 miles. More often than not, they'll need a new clutch and DMF, a new or cleaned DPF, a new turbo, a new EGR.

You can buy a £5000 diesel and have to spend £5000 on it. If you're buying a car with good residuals, you are paying the good residual, you are not benefiting from it unless that car is spectacularly reliable and Audis and BMWs aren't. Mercedes can be okay. Better to get the most for your money with a Ford Fiesta or, bigger, a Toyota Avensis or Lexus IS 250 auto.
Similar questions
I'm looking to buy a used Ford Fiesta, probably no older than 4/5 years. Used mainly for town driving and some long motorway journeys every month. Which is the best engine out of the pre-2013 cars?
I'm currently looking at buying either a 2010 Ford Fiesta Zetec S 1.6 petrol or the TDCi version. I have a 13 mile trip to and from work, which is 80% in town traffic with stopping and starting. As I only...
I need to replace my old Volkswagen Passat diesel estate with something comfortable and reliable. I do less than average mileage and am happy with either a petrol or diesel. Ideally, I want something used...
Related models
Well built with an upmarket interior. Enjoyable and involving to drive. Cheap to run 1.6TDCI ECOnetic. Exceptional reliability record. Very few problems reported despite more than 500,000 sold.
Hugely practical and robust, refined and quiet on the move, excellent diesel engines, especially the 2.0 D-4D, very reliable.