Which is best for a family, estate or MPV?

My wife and I have a large dog and are expecting a baby in March. I currently have a Mazda 6 Estate (2004) but am looking to sell for a newer and bigger option. Whilst I would love another estate and am keen to upgrade to a Mercedes-Benz E-Class or Volvo V70.

However, my wife hates the 'low' driving position of the Mazda and thinks we should buy an MPV due to its space, ease of access, seat height and the fact that she would find it easier to drive (shorter bonnet).

Whilst she may be right about some aspects, I'm not sure an MPV actually has as much boot space as an estate when the rear two seats are down. What type of car would you recommend for our situation?

Asked on 9 December 2014 by reevester

Answered by Honest John

Ford S-Max. It's a seven-seater sportscar and the best compromise. Crucial not to have to bend your backs too much lifting babies and toddlers in and out or you will get disc involvement and regret it for the rest of your life.

Tags: estates mpvs buying a new car family cars

Similar questions

Which family MPV will be reliable and has room for three adults in the back seats?

Our 12-year-old Renault Kangoo is now on its last legs, our Hyundai i20 is too small as a main family car for two adults and three growing kids, and we no longer need two cars. I love the cavernous boot...

Which estate car or MPV for a young family?

My wife and I are expecting our first baby in June and we are in the market for a new car. We also have a dog and have come to the conclusion that we need an estate for when we all go out together. We...

Which small cars rival the Honda Jazz?

We have had three Honda Jazzes and have no complaints about comfort, reliability, versatility, economy etc. However, the market has changed and relative to its current competitors, the Jazz is now an expensive...

Related models