Should I keep my diesel Ford C-Max or replace it?

I am 83 and have a Ford C-Max 1.6 diesel automatic, registered in 2006. I am very concerned about the many reports of gearbox trouble and I am beginning to listen for problems when I am driving now. However, I have found it a splendid car for me, as it's easy to get in and out of, with good all-round visibility and is easy to handle. Would other cars in the C-Max range have the same potential gearbox problems? Which would you recommend? Are there sensible alternatives in other makes? I do not see myself driving for more than about two years and so I could not justify spending more than about £3000 - £4000.

Asked on 28 December 2013 by EH, via email

Answered by Honest John
There isn't really anything else for the money, and the used market for your C-Max is blighted by all the bad news stories. If your C-Max is running fine, you might as well carry on. Just be gentle with it. The problem stems from the torque output of the engine exceeding the capacity of the transmission. But if you avoid accelerating hard from 1500 - 2000rpm you won’t impose maximum torque on the gearbox.
Similar questions
I appear to have seemingly a common fault regarding EGR failure on my 2004 Ford C-Max diesel, where the air pipes were filled with engine oil which the RAC man said was dripping onto the alternator. On...
I am writing you regarding my Ford Focus 1.6TDCI. I purchased it in April 2012 with 38,000 miles on the clock. In October the engine malfunction light came on. I took it into the Ford garage we purchased...
Our 2005 Citroen C8 broke down on the motorway when the cam belt snapped. I understand that when this happens damage can be caused to the engine/valves. The service manual states that the cam belt should...
Related models
Best entry and egress of any car anywhere. Excellent front seat comfort.

Ask Honest John

Value my car