We'd like to replace our underpowered Fiesta with a 1.4-litre Punto - do you have any advice?

Having had two 5-door 1242cc Fiat Puntos and loved them, we then PX’d for a Ford Fiesta 1242cc Style almost three years ago. We have been disappointed with the Ford’s performance. We loved the easy driving feel, power and comfort of the Puntos, especially the lovely light steering. We are now thinking about replacing the 2008 Fiesta for another newer secondhand car (although we are both in our 60s and haven’t got much money). My daughter now has the last Punto we had and I drove it today and realised again how much better it felt to drive than the Ford.

We are thinking about replacing it now with a Punto 5-door 1.4-litre or something as good to drive in our older age. I realise that we will only get perhaps £3000 or less in part-exchange and may be able to add between £6000 to £8000 to that. We would also prefer something not too expensive on insurance, consumption and tax. Are we asking for too much? Do you have any advice for me please?

Asked on 24 August 2013 by GE, via email

Answered by Honest John
This reads as if you picked the 60PS version of the Fiesta 1.25 rather than the 82PS. If that's the case, I'm not surprised. Expect £3000 - £3500 for the Fiesta Style. I’d seriously consider a Dacia Sandero 90TCe at £7395 new.
Similar questions
My wife's car is 2004 Renault Megane Coupe Cabrio in excellent condition with 30,000 miles on the clock. We wish to trade it in for a smaller cheap-to-run car about three years old. The car should be auto,...
Two years ago we replaced our small car in haste with a 1.4 VTR Citroen C2, which we find disappointing in both performance and economy. We are now looking to replace and have shortlisted a 208 1.4 VTI,...
I currently own a Nissan Qashqai 2.0 Acenta 2008, which I bought secondhand in November 2009. Currently we get about 35mpg. We mostly use the car at weekends for longish journeys, with the occasional short...
Related models
Low running costs thanks to economical engines. Impressive MultiAir petrols. Good levels of standard kit. Comes with a driver's knee airbag and five three point seatbelts.
Well built with an upmarket interior. Enjoyable and involving to drive. Cheap to run 1.6TDCI ECOnetic. Exceptional reliability record. Very few problems reported despite more than 500,000 sold.
Unbelievably cheap for this size of car, generous interior space and a big boot, reasonably comfortable to drive.
 

Value my car