Which automatic, economical MPV for under £4000?

My husband and I moved to the Suffolk countryside two years ago, and bought a 2007 Ford C-Max automatic (mileage on purchase: 7000). We already had, and still have, a 2005 Ford Focus automatic. We are both pensioners, but I now have a part-time job which means a round trip of 68 miles per day, three days a week. My husband's voluntary work can mean a round trip of 72 miles per day, varying between once to three times a week.

The C-Max now has a mileage of 47,000 with an average petrol consumption of 33.7mpg, the Focus has a mileage of 78,000 with an average petrol consumption of 33.8mpg. Our thought is to sell one of these cars, and buy a smaller vehicle, but which one should go and what should we buy? Should we run the Focus into the ground and sell the more valuable C-Max, or keep the C-Max? Whatever we buy needs to be automatic because of a medical condition. We have around £3000-£4000 cash to play with.

Asked on 5 January 2013 by PM, Halesworth

Answered by Honest John
Assuming that the C-Max is a 2.0i petrol 4-speed auto, keep the C-Max and sell the Focus. If the C-Max is a 1.6 diesel CVT auto, get rid of it asap before it breaks and keep the Focus. I guess the ideal automatic for you would be a Honda Jazz CVT-7, that should do 40 - 45mpg. I don't recommend any diesel automatics in your price range. Alternatives include a Hyundai i10 1.2 auto, Suzuki Splash 1.2 auto or Vauxhall Agila 1.2 auto, all of which should do up to 45mpg.
Similar questions
I own a Ford B-MAX that is less than three years old. Its about to have its third torque converter fitted to the PowerShift auto box - is this a common fault?
Our 2001 Toyota Previa petrol automatic has been an absolute joy and we've driven every one of its 125,000 miles. Sadly it's beginning to get expensive in its old age and it's time for a change, but Toyota...
My wife is thinking of changing her excellent Toyota RAV4 petrol automatic for a smaller vehicle which is a petrol automatic with a chain cam engine. Reliability is paramount, followed by ride quality...
Related models
Best entry and egress of any car anywhere. Excellent front seat comfort.
Superb blend of keen handling and ride comfort. Seats five in comfort. five-star Euro NCAP crash test rating.
Neatly styled. Increased room and better performance than original Jazz. better to drive. Very versatile. CVT-7 returned in February 2011 replacing i-SHIFT. More reliable than first generation Jazz.
Easy to drive and refined. Very well built. Five-year warranty as standard. Neat and tidy styling. Decent room in the back seat. Good economy from entry-level 1.2-litre.
Small yet tall five-door city car. High seating position. Rear seats fold flat. Auto is 4-speed torque converter. Highest first time MoT pass rate of any car.
Surprisingly spacious small five-door city car. Makes best sense with 1.0 petrol engine. Much better than old Agila. Rebadged version of Suzuki Splash.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer