I want a comfortable, economical car to replace a Smart?

I am about to get rid of a 10-plate Smart car and I am used to getting between 45 to 50mpg. I have a budget of around £3000 for a second hand car and am looking for similar MPG?

I'd like something with a relatively nice interior. Interior is more important to me than exterior - I like an arm rest.

I am in need of more space (for the family at weekends) than a Smart car can offer so I am now looking at a medium sized car. I do like big comfy cars but need the mpg.

It should be an automatic, preferably, but that's not a deal breaker.

I do around 500 miles a week, on a few country lanes but 99% on motorways - I'm not scared of a high mileage car as long as you think it can live on and survive that mileage for 51 weeks (I give myself a week of rest) a year for 2 to 3 years - so reliability is also important!

I have been looking at roughly 8 to 10 year old diesels between 1.5-litres to 2.2-litres from Megane to Focus to Civic - pretty much anything that falls into that category.

Asked on 29 May 2013 by LLcoolLL

Answered by Honest John
Mitsubishi Colt 1.5 diesel or Smart ForFour 1.5 diesel (same 3 cylinder engine).
Dear Honest John,

Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
    Select a few terms below
Similar questions
After this spell of bad weather I think I might feel better about the future if I changed my car. At present I have a 3 door 08 Mitsubishi Colt with 26k mileage, and want to sell it to buy something else....
What is the Real MPG of the 2013 Vauxhall Corsa 1.0 petrol?
I am looking to replace my 2007 Volkswagen Polo with a three year old much more economical small car. It must have air conditioning, five doors and take adults in back. I'm looking at the Toyota Aygo and...
Related models
Affordable to run, Ralliart version is great fun to drive, feels robust and reliable.
Funky-looking, versatile hatch with plenty of safety kit. Manual versions drive well. Four stars for the diesels, by far the best in the line-up.
Roomier than previous version with better seats. More comfortable drive. Cheap to run.