Which MPV to replace the discontinued Fiat Multiplas?

For the past ten years we have racked up a quarter of a million miles in four successive Fiat Multiplas; much of this going to and from the south of France carrying everything from six adults in leg stretching comfort to building materials, wardrobes, several motorbikes and many combinations of such. Now it seems that this awesome and underrated vehicle has been discontinued.

With what can we replace it? Our hopes for the Yeti were dashed today when we saw how tiny it is inside and the internet seems riddled with horror stories about the KIA Sorento's fuel consumption. What please, would you advise?

Asked on 28 July 2012 by JB, Hitchin

Answered by Honest John
I suggest the Mazda 5 1.6d TS2 (it has to be TS2 to get it on sensible 205/44 R16 tyres). This is one of the most comfortable cars in existence, handles brilliantly, has a very well-matched engine and transmission and mine did 48.1mpg over 11,000 miles before I handed it back. I suppose you could also consider a Grande Scenic 1.6DCI 130 and a Grand C-Max 1.6TDCI 115, which has the same engine as the Mazda 5.
Similar questions
I'm a Motability hirer. For three years, I have driven a diesel Nissan Qashqai 1.5 and had no DPF problems whilst doing mainly short runs and covering 20,000 miles. My real mpg is approximately 45 - 60...
Three of my last four vehicles have been Renault Espaces. As Renault no longer offers an Espace in the UK, and not being enamoured with the Grand Scenic, I am looking to change and downsize. My current...
We have had very satisfactory service from our Fiat Multipla JTD ELX which is now 10 years old, has covered over 140,000 miles and, although running well, should perhaps be replaced. We do about 12,000...
Related models
Brilliant, eccentric and superbly practical six-seater.
Comfortable for seven. Great chain-cam 1.4 TCe 130 engine. Brilliant new chain-cam 1.6 dCi 130 diesel engine from mid 2011.
Unique styling. Solid build. Excellent petrol engines including frugal yet peppy 1.2 TSI. Good space in the back. Frugal 1.6 TDI Greenline can return 60mpg+.
Family friendly seven seater. Sport has remote electric sliding side doors. Economical and light new 1.6 diesel. Compliant suspension astonishingly good on poor road surfaces.
Neat styling. More practical than a Focus. Fine blend of ride comfort, handling and driver enjoyment. 1.6 TDCi emits 119g/km. High quality interior.

Value my car