Can I get your opinion on problems that people have with car rental?

The Telegraph Motoring team recommended that I get in touch with you. By way of introduction, I’m a researcher on Watchdog Daily (a new daily strand of Watchdog going on air next month). I was hoping I might be able to give you a call to discuss admin charges in car insurance policies. We’re looking for an expert to interview on the subject tomorrow. Please do give me a call (contact details below) to let me know if you’re available/interested.

Asked on 15 December 2012 by SD, BBC Media Centre, London, W12 7TQ

Answered by Honest John
Unfortunately that won't work because I'm on the other side of the world. It won't even work on Skype because the internet here is heavily under-invested and very slow. But the story is pretty simple.

The money in car rental is made on the insurance. Don't take out the maximum insurance and the rental company might well find damage on the car after its return that it then bills to your credit card. Outfits like www.insurance4carhire.co.uk offer much cheaper annual cover. But if you have this rather than the rental company's insurance then the rental company is more likely to find damage. The golden rule on returning a car is to arrive at least four hours before your flight. Then you have time to make absolutely sure you go over the car with the rental rep and the damage sheet and take at least 40 photos of the car: wheel rims, bumpers, everything, so they can't bill you for damage you did not do. Get back to the airport with only minutes to spare and you are asking to be ripped off.

Two other rip-offs include excess charges for Portuguese tolls. There are no tollbooths on a main stretch of motorway so you have to buy tickets from shops, and many hirers are not told about this. Also paying for a full tank of petrol whether you use it or not, and whether you fill the tank before returning the car or not.

Update: Watchdog Daily covered Private Parking Charges brilliantly in November. It’s a very solid programme.
Similar questions
Our daughter has just suffered a rear-end shunt sustaining severe damage to her Audi. Fortunately, she is signed up with the Audi Ensurance scheme who will deal with the claim for her alongside her regular...
My son took his Dacia Duster in for its first service and was given a loan car. There was a fault on his car and a replacement part is needed but it is not known when this will be available in the UK....
I live in Switzerland and travel back to UK regularly, often needing to rent a car. I used to be able to buy excess insurance for car hire on an annual basis, as a Swiss resident, from UK firms. However...
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer