Audi A3 - almost too good to be true?

I have been investigating an Audi A3 1.8 TFSI (2008) that's been selling for a little below market value (according to Whatcar's free valuations). I have done a vehicle check on it using autotrader's service and it has come back with no adverse data recorded.

On the face of it, it all checks out. It apparently has full main dealer service history (a fact that I will be asking for confirmatory documentation on when I go to view the car), and appears to be in fairly good condition. It has 48k miles on the clock.

I can't help being suspicious of the sale price though. It's a trade advert I came across on autotrader (white cottage car centre in Mirfield), yet it seems to be sold at below what is expected?

Is this as suspicious as I am feeling it is? Or have I really lucked out and happened across a bargain? What advice can you give me in terms of what to look for (with Audi A3s of this age and mileage in particular), and vital information that I can get from the dealer (or anyone else)?

Asked on 15 June 2012 by Stormtec

Answered by Honest John
Our used car pricefinder that automatically checks all advertised prices at that moment in time came up with

Most adverts are between
£8,550 and £10,650

We see cars like this for sale
less than once a week
At a dealer, aim to pay between £8,750 and £11,300
At an independent dealer, expect to pay £10,150.
At a car supermarket, expect to pay £10,000.
From a private seller, aim to pay between £8,350 and £10,350
and expect to pay £9,600.
Similar questions
I am interested in buying a used Kia Optima. I have a specific budget, so is it reasonable to ask the dealer on the telephone if there is any movement on the price? (If I have seen something similar, or...
I just bought a second hand car from an authorised audi dealer, complete with warranty etc. The car had been originally sold by them and serviced inbetween. The car is fine (so far) but on returning...
I visited a main dealer this week. Told the salesman what I wanted - nearly new. He phoned me later, offering a car registered Feb 2012 with delivery miles, for £9999. Yes please, I said, and gave my...
Related models
Good choice of engines. Some petrol engines now chain cam. Comfortable and well built interior. cheap to run 1.6 TDI. Feels very refined especially on the motorway.