Why are used Porsche Cayman prices way over the guide price valuations?

I am looking for a Porsche Cayman around £17,000 for my wife. We really like the car and I think we could afford one for doing around 6,000 miles a year. I am happy with a slightly higher mileage car if the service history is good, but all the cars I look at are overpriced by around £2,000 compared to the price guide valuations - even if they are private sales. Is there a reason for this and what are my chances of getting one at the prices identified in the price guides?

Asked on 12 May 2011 by AL, Blackburn

Answered by Honest John
Higher mileage is better because Porsche prices are extremely mileage sensitive. But my feedback shows that little-used watercooled Porsches are far more likely to show serious problems than cars that have been daily drivers. This will become your problem too, if you don't use the car enough.
Similar questions
I recently almost bought a silver 2006 BMW 330i M Sport coupe for £9400, but I pulled out because of the mileage - it had covered 91,000 miles. What do you think of such a purchase, of a fairly young car...
I want to buy a Honda Jazz 2003 1.3 which has 100,000 miles on it. Is this a high mileage vehicle? It is in good running condition. Is this worth up to £1800, and how many more miles will this engine run...
I have been considering purchasing a 2002 C220 Mercedes-Benz CDI Avantgarde Estate. It has FSH, has completed 89,000 miles and is being sold by a reputable dealer for £6495. I have just retired and do...
Related models
Superbly balanced and agile with amazing grip. Relatively refined and comfortable enough for everyday use. Available with double-clutch PDK gearbox.

 

Value my car