Would you suggest the Land Rover Discovery 4 or the Audi A7 to replace my Range Rover Vogue?

I currently have a 2007 Range Rover TDV8 Vogue but it’s due for change. I'm afraid my budget won't allow me to get another, this is my second and I've loved them both. I'm looking at an new Audi A7 3.0 TDI S-Line and a Discovery 4 3.0HSE - the seven-seat issue is important. I'd welcome your view on what is the best car to live with. I do 40,000 miles a year and, for the most part, its loaded with people and stuff. I don't really do any off-roading.

Asked on 27 October 2010 by DM, London EC3

Answered by Honest John
More room for seven people in the Discovery 4 and no evidence that the Q7 is any more reliable. Ex-Highways Agency Discoveries appear at auction with 175,000 miles or more on them. But the Q7 3.0V6 TDI is chain cam and the Disco 2.7 and 3.0V6s are belt cam.
Similar questions
As a parent-to-be, I have found out that the boot of my BMW 320d Touring is not going to be big enough to accommodate anything other than a small pram. I'm therefore looking for something with more boot...
Our neighbours are moving abroad and are offering us their 2004 Porsche Cayenne Turbo S (4.5-litre V8) with 104,000 miles plus their 1997 Mercedes-Benz SLK 230 Kompressor with 78,000 miles for £8000 (for...
I have a C4 Grand Picasso which will be three years old next month. I bought it with 18 months warranty left. It's served us well and we're really happy with it, the seven seats are something we use occasionally...
Related models
Now has the 3.0 litre V6 diesel engine it really needed. Still unstoppable off-road. Classy image. Refined and high-quality interior. More power and lower emissions from 2012.
Spacious and luxurious interior. A rarity on the roads so ensures exclusivity. 3.0 BiTDI engine with 313PS is immense. Black Edition models available.

Ask Honest John

Value my car