Can I get a reliable car for £5000?
After owning a 2010 BMW 335i and it becoming a money pit in recent years (as much fun as the car is) I'm looking for something inexpensive and reliable to switch to. Can a budget of £3000-£5000 achieve that?
I was thinking of a Japanese hatchback, but am open to other options & recommendations. I was looking at something like a Civic from around 2010 or the Auris from the same era however finding decent ones has been a challenge as, like my BMW, they are quite old cars now but some look really rather tired and uncared for.
I think sticking to looking at petrols is sensible given inflated current prices due to the Iran war. My usage will almost entirely be motorway commuting (25 mile journeys, so I was looking for the slightly higher spec cars with cruise control), the odd longer one and local short trips. I want to feel as though I'm in a solid, reliable car.
From my searches, it feels like you get less for your money now than pre-covid where cheap, good cars were aplenty. Am I right in thinking that doesn't seem to be the case anymore?
Have you any recommendations or advice? Should I look at newer cars instead if avoiding return trips to the garage is something I'd like to minimise following the BMW? Are there still good, cheap reliable cars out there?
Many thanks
I was thinking of a Japanese hatchback, but am open to other options & recommendations. I was looking at something like a Civic from around 2010 or the Auris from the same era however finding decent ones has been a challenge as, like my BMW, they are quite old cars now but some look really rather tired and uncared for.
I think sticking to looking at petrols is sensible given inflated current prices due to the Iran war. My usage will almost entirely be motorway commuting (25 mile journeys, so I was looking for the slightly higher spec cars with cruise control), the odd longer one and local short trips. I want to feel as though I'm in a solid, reliable car.
From my searches, it feels like you get less for your money now than pre-covid where cheap, good cars were aplenty. Am I right in thinking that doesn't seem to be the case anymore?
Have you any recommendations or advice? Should I look at newer cars instead if avoiding return trips to the garage is something I'd like to minimise following the BMW? Are there still good, cheap reliable cars out there?
Many thanks
Asked on 10 April 2026 by AD18
Answered by
Matt Robinson
You're thinking along the right lines with the Civic and Auris - Honda and Toyota each have excellent reliability records. They're a much better bet if you're looking to avoid the repeat garage trips you've mentioned - you don't necessarily need to spend more money to get something dependable.
You're also right that used car prices are generally higher than they were before Covid. Vehicles are still generally holding onto their value better than previously due to what's been happening in the new-car market with things like supply chain issues.
The only thing you can do is expand your search area to get a better variety of prices and ensure you get something representing decent value for money. There can be a wide variety in prices, particularly when comparing a dealer which can afford to hang onto stock for a long term versus a motivated private seller.
You're also right that used car prices are generally higher than they were before Covid. Vehicles are still generally holding onto their value better than previously due to what's been happening in the new-car market with things like supply chain issues.
The only thing you can do is expand your search area to get a better variety of prices and ensure you get something representing decent value for money. There can be a wide variety in prices, particularly when comparing a dealer which can afford to hang onto stock for a long term versus a motivated private seller.
Tags:
buying advice
Similar questions
I'm looking to replace a 55 plate Ford Focus diesel with a similar-size family hatchback, this time petrol. Reliability and economy are top of the list. I'm currently doing 25 miles a day on A roads and...
My London based 26-year-old grandson wishes to purchase his first car for occasional journeys out of London, especially to play golf. He wants a fun 'snazzy' car to drive that will take his golf clubs...
What is the most reliable family automatic hatchback for under £4500? I was set on Civic 1.8 2009 but then learned that this model has the i-Shift which is best avoided.
Related models
.jpg?width=115&height=75&rmode=crop)
Practical and comfortable cabin, huge amounts in interior space, great 2.2 i-CTDi diesel engine, well built and reliable, enjoyable to drive.
Elsewhere on 
