Should I choose a low mileage car over one with a higher mileage?

I’m looking at two Jaguar E-Paces, one 2018 with 70K and one 2019 with 40K. Should the difference in mileage urge me to purchase one over the other?

Asked on 9 January 2024 by Sophie Coleman

Answered by David Ross
Mileage is just one variable to consider when looking at a used car, as this needs to be balanced against condition, history, specification and price. Although the lower mileage example may seem the more desirable option, it could be that this car has performed lots of short journeys, whether the other has been used mostly on motorways which is less wearing on a vehicle.
Similar questions
If a car is 4 years old but very low mileage is it worth buying?
Which car is the better buy, in terms of reliability and resale value - a new Toyota Aygo or a MINI One with 20,000 miles on the clock?
Our dealer sourced us a 2012 Hyundai ix 35. We agreed a £300 deposit when we make appointment to test drive we are told the mileage is 13k, not 7k as he told us when he phoned to say he had sourced it....
Related models
Sporty little SUV. Plug-in hybrid P300e can travel up to 38 miles under electric power alone. Much improved infotainment system from 2021.