I want to replace my aging Ford Ka with something reliable, but a bit more robust - what do you suggest?

I'm looking to change my car in 6-12 months time. I drive a Ford Ka, which I have had since new and it will be six years old this year. I currently drive along a lot of A and B rural roads, so I'm looking for something a bit more robust. However, I'm not sure whether to go down the SUV road or upgrade to a slightly bigger car. Whatever I get will need to be economical and reliable as a priority. Also, I don't have a family to drive around so I'm wondering whether I actually need a very large family car for one person. I would love to have a convertible or something sporty but not sure that's the most practical option. I've got absolutely no idea what to even look at.

Asked on 2 March 2020 by Veronica Bancroft

Answered by Andrew Brady
How about a Ford Fiesta? It's bigger than your Ka, so will feel more robust, while also being reliable and cheap to run. It's also fun to drive and you could opt for the rugged Active model if you want something a little more SUV-like. Also, consider small crossover SUVs like the new Ford Puma, Peugeot 2008 and Volkswagen T-Cross. These have higher seating positions - which might be good for the kind of driving you do - without being significantly bigger or more expensive to run than a hatchback. As a left-field choice, if you don't need much in the way of practicality, take a look at a Mazda MX-5. They're reliable and cheap to run, while also being sporty and fun to drive.
Similar questions
I’m looking to buy a car which I’m able to fit my son's BMX in. I currently have a Focus. He’s not 11 and due to the boot lip he does struggle getting it in and out easily. I’m disabled so can’t help him....
I have an old Volvo C70. I use the back seats a lot for luggage space. I want another convertible with as much luggage space as possible. What do I want?
What are your top small SUVs?
Related models
Easy to drive and economical. Based on the Fiat 500 but handles much better. More room in rear than 500.
Decent space for adults in the back. Low load sill. Significantly improved by 1.2 PureTech engine. EGC replaced by excellent EAT6 torque converter auto.
Superb handling, very reliable, good parts support, excellent value for money, lots of fun. (Model designation NA.)
Most versions good to drive, especially ST-Line but significantly more refined. Comfortable and practical. Comes with active safety technology as standard.
Comfortable and easy to drive. Surprisingly practical and spacious. Excellent 1.0-litre petrol.
'Crossover' version of Ford Fiesta with raised ride height that gives more compliant suspension than standard Fiesta.
Fiesta-based crossover is excellent to drive. Surprisingly practical. Generous amount of standard equipment.
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car