What car for my varied needs?

My needs are varied. Most trips tend to be in the city with the occasional long trip and an annual journey to the Black Forest in Germany.

I thought of a supermini estate (Pug 207SW), but people tell me to avoid all Peugeots. It may not be a good long distance cruiser.

So in today's austere times which car is better for the above scenarios, a Peugeot 308SW or Volvo V50 or Mercedes-Benz A-Class?



Asked on 5 December 2011 by ukievas

Answered by Honest John
A-Class about to be replaced. V50 nice but now long in the tooth (DRIVEe cheap to run and tax). 308SW and smaller 207SW okay, best with 1.6THP 156 petrol engine that will do 40 - 45mpg.
Similar questions
I have a MINI Cooper D auto, which is a great little car and lots of fun. However, to be practical, I really need something not quite so mini and a softer ride for the Suffolk lanes on which it is used....
My wife and I are around retirement ages. We live in WC1, but drive frequently to Devon, sometimes with loads: either family or furniture. Either way the load tends to be bulky and, sometimes heavy. We...
I am in the market for a 1 year old, small/med diesel estate. I have never owned a diesel before and am concerned about what I read re DMFs. I have narrowed field to Peugeot 308SW, Vauxhall Astra Tourer,...
Related models
Versatile update of 307SW on 308 floorpan. 3 x Isofix sliding, folding centre rear seats. Excellent handling. THP 150 6-speed best.
Classy-looking compact estate with very good ride comfort and tidy handling. A fine long-distance cruiser. The UK's most popular Volvo.