Buying Mercedes CLC coupe sport; petrol or diesel - value for money?

I have recently been looking at buying a 2008 Mercedes-Benz CLC 180 petrol coupe with 20,000 miles on the clock for £13,990, or the 2008 CLC 220 CDi diesel with 11,000 miles for £16,500.

Performance wise I understand they are both roughly the same, I will obviously get better mpg with the diesel, but is it worth the extra £3k for this and the lower mileage?

They are both from the Mercedes dealership (which gives me piece of mind in that I get the 12months warranty - both cars are also still covered by manufacturers warranty till Dec 11)

Are they both good value?

I am also being informed by colleagues and the dealership, Fords of Winsford, that they do not move on the price for cash. They claim that they make money on the finance and would prefer people to use finance than cash...is this correct?

I have gone to a dealership as I want the peace of mind that I wont be spending this kind of money on a private sale and inheriting a car with problems. I don't want to only have the manufacturers warranty to fall back on for six months.

With the dealership being a Mercedes-Benz one I also know that they have had full Mercedes-Benz service history and that they do a complete check and report on the car.

Is there anything else I should be thinking of or worrying about?

Asked on 17 March 2011 by Nevitt237

Answered by Honest John
That will be Fords of Winsford. Very good reputation for decent cars at sensible money. But a 2008 diesel is just about to start to suffering what could amount to £5k + worth of problems over the extra 3 years so I'd go for the £3k cheaper petrol and save £8k.
Dear Honest John,

Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
    Select a few terms below
Similar questions
Considering Mercedes CLC '08/'10 180 Kompressor petrol auto. Daily drive is five miles, weekly some 30 mile trips, monthly an occasional 60+ miles. Should I go for a diesel auto though? Don't like...
My son wants to buy a Ford Mondeo estate. It would be a 3 year old car and he would hope to keep it for around 6 years. He does about 25K per year and the deal he has with his work means that he pays for...
I' planning to buy either a Toyota Yaris (2009-2011) or Ford Fiesta (2008 onwards). Which of the two do you recommend for reliability, holding its value well, build quality and running costs. I'm planning...
Related models
Bolder looking replacement for C-Class Coupe, wide range of engines, neat interior.