Valetta parking

My wife and I have reached an impasse when trying to choose a new car. For most of the year, we live in Gozo: a wonderfully old-fashioned, sunkissed hideaway, one of the Maltese group of islands - with not-so-wonderful old-fashioned roads full of potholes and temperatures that can reach 40 in August. It is such a small island that cars rarely attain speeds above 50 mph. Every year, in November, we drive back to England, with our dog and a fully-loaded car: through Sicily, Italy and France. Depending on the route it means that the journey can be up to 2000 miles, mostly on Autostrada/ Autoroutes. We then spend three months in Kent in the rain and snow before making the return journey in March with a suspension-testing load of purchases. My wife's trusty 10-year old Hyundai Accent has made this journey 8 times but it is time that we upgraded to something bigger and better. Now we come to our dilemma: we have refined the choice to either a RAV 4 or a Kia Sportage - each has a bewildering variety of different specifications available. I incline towards the Toyota whilst my wife feels that the Kia is better value for money and will still be suitable for touring holidays in Europe. Your advice on type and model would be most welcome.

Asked on 3 April 2010 by A.M., Sutton Valence

Answered by Honest John
RAV-4s are now very expensive. A new Hyundai Santa Fe 2.2 194hp is not only better, and stronger, but carries a 5-year rather than a 3-year warranty. But it's big. There is a new KIA Sportage on the way: a clone of the new Hyundai ix35, both built at the KIA factory in Slovenia rather than the Hyundai factory in the Czech Republic. The 2.0-litre chain cam R-Type diesel engines emit less than 150g/km. It’s also worth looking at a KIA Soul, though that might not be big enough. Or a Nissan Qashqai. Always go for the smallest wheels with deepest profile tyres available to absorb the shocks. Living on Gozo, though, you may have trouble regenerating the DPFs of diesel engines in the colder months of the year
Similar questions
Buying New 4x4 (not 4x2 version) but it will only cover 3000 miles/per annum. As all modern diesels have DPFs we can't have a diesel, so besides Suzuki Grand Vitara & Kia Sportage, what else? Unless someone...
I am looking for a 4x4. My garage has recommended a Honda CR-V, a Toyota RAV 4 or a Nissan Qashqai. I have never driven a 4x4 so it is important I find one that is easy to drive. I am not a long distance...
I need a replacement for a 2010 Skoda TDi Octavia Scout (which has been a very good car - have loved the elevated seating position which is a must in my new car). I am looking now as the Scout took over...
Related models
Bigger and now 5-door only. More luxurious but not as practical as previous RAV-4. Car-like road manners. Petrol and diesel automatics. Facelifted 2010.
Stylish and upmarket looks. Good quality feel to the interior. Seven-year warranty as standard. Very low CO2 for an SUV. Well equipped.