High mileage & a recent revelation - at6077

Hi all

Thank you for your help so far however some recent news has led to some more head scratching.

My wife recently started a new job and has just revealed to me that as a company perk she will receive £2500 per annum for a car as long as the car is no more than 4 years old. The idea being it would seem that employees get a new car, use the company perk to finance it for 4 years before trading in for another new model and repeat the cycle. So far so good.

So we are thinking we'll we could take a new car on finance, sell the second hand one (purchased just over 5 months ago allready second hand) and let her company pay for it all.

given it'ts the wifes perk she gets the big say on the car (which is fair!) and the contender is a mini.

Peversly though it'll be me that drives since she simply walks to work whilst I now do an average of 35,000 miles a year thanks to my new job (hence the purchase of a car back in March that was much more fuel efficient, 2010 Seat Ibiza Ecomotive, i've now done 10k allready. We have no finance, it was bough outright).

So i;ve been having a look about and the main issue I'm seeing is mileage, most finance offers seem to only go up to 10k per annum before sticking you with a charge per mile after. This charge would effectively wipe out the company allowance.

So i'm basically asking you all what would potentially be the best course of action. right now I've shifted away from the idea of buying a new car and simply using her allowance to pay for the Ibizas insurance for the next couple of years and then re work things out. However the Ibiza would then have a lttle over 100k miles on the clock and it's trade in value would be negligable so we would have the problem again of excess mileage on the next car if we took out finance.

alternatively I would hazard to say that best alternatve woul dbe to get a loan from the bank for a new car, use the car grant to pay it off over 4 years (or as much as possible) and buy the new car outright thereby avoiding the excess mileage charge completely. The only issue here is will the bank lend to us, given that they are being nice and stingy for everbody!

Apologies for length but I'm trying to navigate to the best possible solution and a fresh set of eyes and thoughts would be appreciated.

High mileage & a recent revelation - barney100
You could think of changing the car every year, you would be under warranty all the time and would have your 2.5k year to go towards a new car.
High mileage & a recent revelation - Collos25

Have included BIK company insurance and the fact the 2500 is taxable we receive 6000 less tax and its still financially better to run your own car and claim mileage.Also do not forget that any agreement you or your wife signs is yours and if she loses her job for any reason you are still liable for the debt.

Edited by Collos25 on 21/07/2012 at 09:09

High mileage & a recent revelation - bazza

Does she receive the £2500 regardless of whether she spends it on a car or not? If so, just keep the Seat and use the money to run it. Or is it more complicated than that?

High mileage & a recent revelation - Collos25

Agreed but its 2500 less tax and if like me she is in the high tax bracket then 40%disappears its no wonder there are so many tax dodges in the UK.

High mileage & a recent revelation - 72 dudes

Collos25 is right.

Best to treat the taxable £2500 as help towards running a car rather than a way to get the company to finance another one.

Use it to run the Seat and help offset the depreciation when it comes time to replace that car. Ideally, place the "perk" money in a savings account and leave it there.

A couple of years back I looked into going down the Personal Contract Hire route - the thought of running a new car for 3 years seemed appealing. Now without a job for the time being, I am so glad I didn't!

High mileage & a recent revelation - at6077

Thank you for all your messages, it hadn't even occured to me that the £2500 would be taxable, that certainly changes things a bit!

Bazza- she only receives the £2500 (or up to £2500) if requested for a car. We can't (unfortunately) simply claim that £2500 and use it for a holiday or simply squirrel it away in the bank for a rainy day.

We are waiting to find out what exactly are the strings attached (she's only eligible for the perk in a couple of months time) but after reading yoru comments I think we will be taking the sum and using it to pay for insurance, servicing and fuel on the Seat, at least for the next couple of years. We'll thats the sensible option at any rate, but let's see what happens!

High mileage & a recent revelation - Bobbin Threadbare

That sounds like a good plan. A relative of mine gets an expenses allowance from his company in this manner, which he is basically instructed to use for fuel, ityres, insurance, VED etc. It's not enough to put to a car (certainly not with his penchant for top end Audis) but it covers all his fuel for doing very high mileages.