Need your advice people. - ray44

Hi Everyone.

Wonder if I can get some advice ASAP.

I was in a small bump a couple of months ago. I finally got round to getting my car collected by the authorised repair agent set up by my insurance company. This repair was with a body shop only as the car was drivable and was in fact driven to the repairers by the guy who dropped off the loan car.

A couple of weeks later a received a call saying my car was ready for collection but it now wouldnt start. Cut a long story short they had the car trailered back to my address and i still had to pay my excess of £300! Just had my car repaired by another garage as the Timing chain had slipped. This cost me £500!

My question is, do i case against the body shop by not returning my car in working order? Or is it just one of those things?

All advice welcome.

Ray

Need your advice people. - Avant

In order to lay blame on the body shop, you'd have to prove that the repair to the small bump, or anything else that was done at the body shop, in some way affected the timing chain. That may be difficult.

Need your advice people. - oldroverboy

What car, what engine, it takes a lot to slip a timing chain, so tell us if the car has been serviced as per manufacturer, lucky it was only £500....

Need your advice people. - injection doc

Hi Ray

A little more information would help ? Make and model ? If the chain had jumped in the bump I would of expected the engine light to of appeared !. There may be a date of a recorded fault in the ECU.

If its a Nissan Almera or Micra its common ! for chains

Need your advice people. - oldtoffee

So the last person to drive the car was the repairers driver. I assume it started ok after the bump and drove off ok so the slip must have occurred on the drive back or at the body shop. If the slip occurred at the time of the bump surely the driver would have noticed something was wrong in the way it drove or as injection doc says a warning light would have lit up and the driver would surely be savvy enough to know what that meant. To my simple mind you could present this logic to the repairers and ask them to make a hefty contribution or you'll seek legal advice and pursue them for the full damages.

Need your advice people. - madf

You have no recourse. If you place the car in someone's care and it breaks down, it is your responsibility unless you can prove they deliberately mistreated it AND that would damage a well maintained car.

Most timing chain tensioners depend on an oil pressure based tensioner to prevent the chain jumping off the sprockets. A worn tensioner/engine can over time leak oil so when the engine is started after a couple of weeks, the tensioner does not tension at first.

Bang goes the chain.

Tough luck I think.

(and if I were defending and you do not have a FULL service history that is the defence I would give. You would be very fortunate to win against it.

Need your advice people. - injection doc

The garage also have a "duty of care" so some responsibility lies with the garage. The car was driven away ok from the OP's house.

There have been a fair few incidents reported of timing chains or camshafts snapping after rear end shunts, including a few on this forum. Whether its coincedence or not requires further investigation.