Resting foot on clutch - Rattle
My car has no where to rest my foot. So I have been resting on the clutch pedal but I have found that when I do this a little bit of preasure is being applied. Is this causing any damage or does the clutch plate not begin to open to quite high up? Is there way I can test this by looking at the clutch cable?
Resting foot on clutch - Lud
Don't do that Rattle. It may cause wear to the thrust bearing. You can't check it by looking at the clutch cable.

Put your foot on the floor under the pedal.

You're just trying to wind us up aren't you?
Resting foot on clutch - Rattle
Sadly not :( I was driving along as usual and just suddenly realised that while my foot is on the clutch I could be putting preasure on it and as you say causing damage to the bearing (didn't know it was the thrust bearing, but knew it was a bearing).

Since realising this I have just tried to put my foot over the clutch slightly to left. I've done 1400 miles in this now and there dosn't seem to be any damage but changing gear is sometimes a little notchy but I suppose after 82k the syncronmesh is slightly worn.

I would say if any pedal travel was being asserted it would be about 50mm if that. My throttle cable dosn't even respond to anything from until I put about 150mm of preasure onto it (used to it now).

I learnt from my old car after burning out the clutch not to leave the clutch down at lights so at least I have learnt that lesson :).

Its better to learn this things on an old £1k car than on an a new £10k diesel with a DFM :D.
Resting foot on clutch - Old Navy
My throttle cable dosn't even respond to anything from until I put about
150mm of preasure onto it (used to it now).


Ever thought of adjusting it, should take all of five minutes, 150mm is a lot of slack, it must restrict the engine revs dramatically.
Resting foot on clutch - grumpyscot
Do we assume you didn't road test the car before you bought it?
Resting foot on clutch - jase1
I would say if any pedal travel was being asserted it would be about 50mm
if that.


Two inches?!?

That'd be about bite point on some cars I've driven! Definitely at the point where wear is a problem.
Resting foot on clutch - Cliff Pope
I think what Rattle is getting at is that aside from the pedal travel to engage the thrust bearing, and the actual operating travel, there is a small amount of slack in the cable to take up before even the thrust bearing is touched.
If that small give in the cable is spring-loaded, then as long as your foot weight does not exceed the spring resistance, then resting it on the pedal will not actually be putting pressure on, or wearing, anything (OK, marginally stretching the pedal spring after about 50 years).

However, I think most cable set-ups are adjusted to eliminate any cable slack. Certainly 2", if I am reading the post right, is excessive and must be severely limiting real clutch range.
Resting foot on clutch - jase1
Rattle's also saying that there is six inches of travel before any meaningful clutch response -- meaning that the bite-point must be right on the floor.

Something amiss here.
Resting foot on clutch - FotheringtonThomas
Has your car got a choke knob on the dashboard?
Resting foot on clutch - perro
>>> My car has no where to rest my foot. So I have been resting on the clutch pedal <<<

Get an automatic!
Resting foot on clutch - Stuartli
..or a larger car....:-)
Resting foot on clutch - Cliff Pope
Has your car got a choke knob on the dashboard?


It's uncomfortable resting your knee on the choke knob, unless you hang a handbag on it first for padding.
Resting foot on clutch - Rattle
I meant 5mm and 15mm :) I had been working 14 hours when I wrote that :).

All Corsa B's have the slack in the throttle. It dosn't cause any problems it just took a while to get used to.

Resting foot on clutch - pmh3
>>>I meant 5mm and 15mm :) I had been working 14 hours when I wrote that :).<<<


Just as well you didnt take up trauma surgery for a living then!
Resting foot on clutch - glowplug
As a DIYer who's changed a clutch on a couple of modern FWD cars I wouldn't dream of resting my foot on the clutch, holding it in or slipping it. Lots of drivers do though.

Am I being a whimp?

Steve.
Resting foot on clutch - FotheringtonThomas
He's got to have somewhere to hang it....
Resting foot on clutch - 1400ted

All those years of training Ratboy have come to nothing. I think perhaps amputation is the next road to go down...that'll sort you out I.....:-)

Ted
Resting foot on clutch - bell boy
can he not tie his left leg round his neck while he doesnt need to press the clutch?
thats how ive always told auto virgins to get used to an auto first time out
Resting foot on clutch - bathtub tom
Let him change his own clutch.

That'll teach him!

Edited by rtj70 on 01/08/2009 at 00:16

Resting foot on clutch - Rattle
I might buy a few buses instead. Stick 86 in front of them and then start world war three with Brian Souter :p

It would certainly solve my clutch problem. I don't think I have done any harm as I don't think it is ingaging but it is something I need to be aware of.
Resting foot on clutch - Blue {P}
Just put your foot underneath the pedal, it's what I did for years when I had small cars and I never found it caused a problem. The only time that I held my foot above the pedal was when I had first passed and was still nervous about being able to press the right pedals at the right time etc. Soon got over that tho!
Resting foot on clutch - Stuartli
Just put your left foot on the dashboard.....:-)

Edited by Stuartli on 01/08/2009 at 00:43

Resting foot on clutch - carl_a
Just put your foot underneath the pedal it's what I did for years when I
had small cars


Properly designed small cars have clutch rests, I'd never touch any car without one. The Koreans and most of the Japanese cars seem to manage it perfectly well.
Resting foot on clutch - Stuartli
>>Just put your foot underneath the pedal>>

I've got size 11 shoes.....

In any case my VW Bora has a clutch foot rest.

Edited by Stuartli on 01/08/2009 at 09:53

Resting foot on clutch - the swiss tony
>>Just put your foot underneath the pedal>>
I've got size 11 shoes.....


Ive also got size 11's... can't say Ive ever struggled to find somewhere to put my clutch foot out of the way.
Resting foot on clutch - Stuartli
I wasn't inferring that I've ever struggled to find space for the left peg, only that putting it under the clutch pedal (apart from being foolish in my view) would be more trouble than it would be worth.
Resting foot on clutch - Farmer Boy
I wasn't inferring that I've ever struggled to find space for the left peg only

I think you mean IMPLYING!
Resting foot on clutch - bathtub tom
I'm sure my old English teacher used to drum into us:
'I infer, you imply'.

I think nowadays it doesn't really matter.
Resting foot on clutch - bell boy
i always find it a harder situation to jump into something usually french and go to brake with your boots on and end up hitting the accelerator and brake at the same time or even worse,you go to change gear put your foot on the clutch and your same foot on the brake at the same time,by the time you have realised you have stopped very quickly you have to remove your head from the windshield
not nice
Resting foot on clutch - Lud
Oh dear, more complications. You don't wear crocs or work boots or ski boots do you Rattle?

Another solution to your problem would be to put your right foot out of the window and use the left one on brake and accelerator, doing clutchless gear changes.

You will need to practise on a very large empty car park, preferably in someone else's car.
Resting foot on clutch - FotheringtonThomas
Missing the point somewhat. A good smear of superglue around the steering wheel, a dab of it in front of the fourth forward ratio, some under and on the accelerator, and some by the clutch pedal, not on it...

Heigh-ho, Silver!!
Resting foot on clutch - captain chaos
Try wearing winkle pickers...
Resting foot on clutch - Glaikit Wee Scunner {P}
I've driven a Corsa B several times and found absolutely no problems in resting my foot on the floor /under the clutch pedal. Got size 12s as well. Never rest your foot on a clutch pedal- all sorts of premature wear will occur.
My new Skoda is great for comfort with foot rests to the left of the clutch and right of the accelerator. Useful with cruise control.
Resting foot on clutch - jase1
Have to agree with Stuartli and bell boy though that a car without a footrest is an indicator of poor design.

It would be a dealbreaker for me if a car did not have one. You can get around it (our Daewoo lacks one, a carry-over from the Astra it was based on I guess) but it is inconvenient and I only put up with it because the car was free.

French small cars in particular have stupid RHD pedal setups and I personally wouldn't touch one with a bargepole. When I get one as a hire car etc my heart sinks.
Resting foot on clutch - Lud
It amazes me how sensitive and demanding people have become. Almost spoiled one might say.

Poor design indeed! You can't get a quart into a pint pot. If the wheelarch and gear linkage, central console and other gubbins intrude into the driver's foot space there's not much you can do about it except put your spare foot on the floor under the pedals.

Similarly, if the pedals are offset from the driver's seat there's nothing you can do except adopt a lopsided slouch. And if you are driving an Italian car you just have to adopt a gorilla's long-armed, bow-legged stance.

It all happens easily and completely automatically. Never occurs to me to complain or whine. How weird people are.

'I went to Maples for a dining table, and do you know there wasn't a single model with adjustable footrests.'

Tchah!

Edited by Lud on 02/08/2009 at 15:35

Resting foot on clutch - jase1
Poor design indeed! You can't get a quart into a pint pot. If the wheelarch
and gear linkage central console and other gubbins intrude into the driver's foot space there's
not much you can do about it except put your spare foot on the floor
under the pedals.


There's a very easy way around it.

You (politely) tell the 206 dealer to shove his badly-designed jalopy where the sun doesn't shine and go across the road to the bloke who is selling the nice Hyundai Getz with the warranty and the reliability and the indicator stalk on the correct way (another bugbear).

And get a footrest at a cheaper cost...

Edited by Dynamic Dave on 02/08/2009 at 20:42

Resting foot on clutch - Lud
(politely) tell the 206 dealer to shove his badly-designed jalopy where the sun doesn't shine and go across the road to the bloke who is selling the nice Hyundai Getz with the warranty and the reliability and the indicator stalk on the correct way (another bugbear).


See what I mean? Spoiled almost. Here's a geezer with the resources to buy a new or nearly new small car off the peg, and he'd rather have a Hyundai Getz than a Peugeot 206 because the Getz has a footrest.

I despair of the human race (no offence though jase).

:o}
Resting foot on clutch - bathtub tom
>>Similarly, if the pedals are offset from the driver's seat there's nothing you can do except adopt a lopsided slouch.

Take painkillers for the backache and hope it doesn't cause problems when you reach my age.

Youngsters today - pah!
Resting foot on clutch - Cliff Pope
The really important thing is that the window cill should be low enough to rest your elbow on while lazily steering with thumb and forefinger.
Resting foot on clutch - Lud
Youngsters today - pah!


You are trying to flatter me bt.

Of course if you have a back problem this sort of thing becomes much more important, I agree. But so far touch wood in 70 years I haven't had the sort of crippling back thingy that some people suffer from.

Not claiming to be as good as I was at 30 or 40 of course. Back and legs still more or less OK though.
Resting foot on clutch - David Horn
Lud - 70? I doff my hat to you, Sir. You have the wit and sarcasm of a mere 40 year-old. ;-)
Resting foot on clutch - jase1
See what I mean? Spoiled almost. Here's a geezer with the resources to buy a
new or nearly new small car off the peg and he'd rather have a Hyundai
Getz than a Peugeot 206 because the Getz has a footrest.


Nah. I'd have the Getz because I think the 206 is fugly. Even more spoiled I guess!

Anyway, I'm one of the contrary types that'd rather be driving around in a 300 quid Primera (despite being perfectly able to go out and hand over 15 grand in cash tomorrow for a car, and not suffer any ill-effects).
I despair of the human race (no offence though jase).


None taken!
Resting foot on clutch - L'escargot
Have to agree with Stuartli and bell boy though that a car without a footrest
is an indicator of poor design.


Most designs are a compromise. There's often only a certain dimension or amount of space in which to get a number of items, and the manufacturer has to make a judgement as to how the available space is allocated. In this instance the limiting dimension is the overall width of the car. To have a footrest would probably cause worse problems with other items.
Resting foot on clutch - rtj70
My Mondeo didn't have a proper foot rest. I wonder if this is partly down to the conversion to RHD? My Mazda6 does but that was designed with a RHD market in mind.

Edited by rtj70 on 03/08/2009 at 10:19

Resting foot on clutch - Avant
There are some design faults that sound minor but have the capacity to infuriate when you have to live with them every day, and this is one of them I think.

If you do long motorway runs your left foot needs to be comfortable - it doesn't just go away! Or if you have an automatic it needs support all the time unless you left-foot brake.

I haven't looked at one recently but Fords used to be very bad at providing footrests, and is some cases even space for the left foot.

Other faults that are more important than they sound:

- Windscreen wipers set up to favour LHD
- Rear seats in a hatchback or (unforgivably) in an estate that don't fold flat
- Blind spots at the back caused by stupid styling
- Lack of a spare wheel
- Electronic handbrake (no apology for calling that a design fault).
Resting foot on clutch - the swiss tony
Other faults that are more important than they sound:

'Letterbox' windows
digital speedos
small mirrors (I believe there are new regulations on the visibility given now, so hopefully gone forever)
LED rear lights that cant be seen... (e.g. VW indicators when brake lights are on)
cars that are almost impossible to get into (e.g. rear of Merc CLS (Im long in the torso))
Resting foot on clutch - whoopwhoop
More faults which are more important than they sound :

Radios with the most commonly used control (the volume knob) being placed furthest away from the driver - i.e. on the left hand side

Auto windscreen wipers that aren't sensitive enough. Double whammy annoyance factor as cars with auto wipers generally don't have intermittent function grrrrr.

Seatbelt warning buzzers that sound when reversing. (I take my belt off to reverse - as permitted by law - as it's easier to twist and see behind)
Resting foot on clutch - LikedDrivingOnce
Radios with the most commonly used control (the volume knob) being placed furthest away from
the driver - i.e. on the left hand side


Not such a problem if you have volume controls on the steering wheel.
Auto windscreen wipers that aren't sensitive enough. Double whammy annoyance factor as cars with auto
wipers generally don't have intermittent function grrrrr.


Great shout! This drives me nuts!
Resting foot on clutch - Lud
I don't think I've ever come across a car with auto wipers.

Even more than most contemporary bells and whistles, it's a stupid marketing idea for stupid idle people.

Electronic complexity is bad enough when it is there to make cars more reliable, smooth, economical and so on. Having it where you don't need it is just marketing tosh, for wallies.

This is why I want to see a 2CV or Model T for the 21st century, a car without the weight, bulk and built-in random unreliability of all this carp. Not that I want wipers driven off the speedometer cable like the ones in early 2CVs... they were a bit too much of a good thing, like Ford inlet-vacuum operated ones...
Resting foot on clutch - Dynamic Dave
I don't think I've ever come across a car with auto wipers.
it's a stupid marketing idea for stupid idle people.


They still need switching on before they'll work, so less of the idle if you please ;o)
Resting foot on clutch - Lud
less of the idle if you please ;o)


I can tell from other posts that people live with and even like these things DD, so clearly I am no authority on this matter. Still, one has one's prejudices.

What I really like are cars with what you need when driving them, no more. How many things that means depends on the sort of car I suppose.

The Porsche 356 Roadster, a stripped, cheapened version of the Cabriolet for the Californian market (and very successful it was) is a charming little car. Few toys with nice solid manual controls. That's the spirit...
Resting foot on clutch - rtj70
Radios with the most commonly used control ...

But I assume you can reach that far without a problem?
Auto windscreen wipers that aren't sensitive enough.

Auto wipers I had on a Passat and have on current Mazda6 are adjustable. They weren't on the Mondeo. On the Passat if you changed the sensitivity it did an immediate wipe.
Seatbelt warning buzzers that sound when reversing...

I turned them off in the Mondeo (and back on again when it went back 4 years later).

Edited by rtj70 on 03/08/2009 at 16:39

Resting foot on clutch - Stuartli
I have a near 10-year-old VW Bora and, as rtj70 states, the auto wiper function can be varied if required.

However, on the setting I've always left it on, the auto sensing operates in tandem with the level of rainfall and only goes flat out in heavy rain. Otherwise the wipes are intermittent or consistent in steady rain.

Only thing to remember (something corrected in later models) is that you have to choose the auto sensing function manually whenever the ignition has been switched off i.e. go back to the rest position and return to intermittent. I find the auto wipe function far better than having to change between normal and fast speeds.

With regard to the volume control on the Gamma audio unit, the volume control is only a few inches past the tuning knob and easy to reach, apart from the fact that the head unit is fairly low down and the gear lever can get in the way.

However, the volume control isn't used much as there is an automatic volume level increase mode for higher speeds (GALA).
Resting foot on clutch - rtj70
The variable bit I found on the Passat meant the sensitivity for light rain could be changed. I set it and forgot.

The Golf I had also had somewhere to rest the right foot when on cruise control - as well as a place for the left foot.
Resting foot on clutch - Middeo
Just a note on my own experience .

I have this awful habit even though i do have a place to rest my foot.

All 3 cars I have owned so far end up having very loose clutches by the time I get rid of them. I haven't had any repairs to make, all that has happened is that the pedeal becomes easier to press. My current car I have done 20,000 miles in and the bite point hasnt moved at all even though the pedal is easier to press.

Dont know if that helps at all.

Middeo
Resting foot on clutch - jase1
Well the bite point most likely won't move, it's the release bearing that takes the strain.

Not sure why the clutch feel would change though, not in a hydraulic clutch anyway.
Resting foot on clutch - Lud
Not sure why the clutch feel would change though


hydraulic cylinder bores and pivots, often set up with a bit of resistance in new cars, get polished - run in - over time. And return springs soften as well, including the clutch diaphragm.
Resting foot on clutch - Middeo
Yeah in mine its definately the return springs that have changed as I can lift the pedal back up anbout 5cm to where it used to be.
Resting foot on clutch - 1400ted
In the Jowett, you can rest your clutch foot on the dipswitch.......very convenient for night driving. There's no transmission tunnel or gearbox in the way, even with rwd, so you can stretch your left leg as far as your passenger will allow !....progress ?

Ted
Resting foot on clutch - Avant
"This is why I want to see a 2CV or Model T for the 21st century...."

Ted's mention of his Javelin reminded me of how extraordinary it was that Jowett could produce beauty (Javelin and Jupiter) at the same time as ugliness (Bradford).

The Bradford was, like the 2CV and Renault 4, the basic no-frills utility car that Lud is seeking: the Berlingo and Kangoo may be the nearest we get nowadays. They come with creature comforts - at least they do here, as Brits want them.

The French like their base models and probably have fewer problems with their cars' electrics as a consequence. Would a stripped out base Berlingo sell in the UK? I'm not sure - perhaps because for Citroen to make a profit it wouldn't sell for that much less than what we have now.
Resting foot on clutch - Rattle
My mates brand new Panda might fit the bill. No leather steering wheel etc. It has central locking, EW and PAS but that is about as far as it goes. It has ABS but no ESP, it has hollow head rests (remember them!). No aircon and just two airbags it really is a simple car, oh and it has an 8V engine (remember them!).

It just seems to be a great simple and well thought out cheap little car.

My last car was a sit up and beg (Encore rather than Popular though, Ford got rid of that name plate). No electric windows, no PAS, no central locking, uselsss ventalation etc etc. Never ever again. My car has luxeries such as electric mirrors and I use them quite often. All the gadgets work even after 82k and ten years.

It makes driving a lot easier and more pleasurable. Maybe my next car will have a place to rest the clutch though!
Resting foot on clutch - bell boy
my electric mirrors work too
but
i only know this when im parked somewhere
and bored bored bored
they could be handy if i was a private detective following a mass murderer from house to car i suppose as i sat low in my seat smoking my Gaulloises cigarettes and eating an onion as i read le figaro----
Resting foot on clutch - Rattle
Exactly Bellbody its quite cool. You have an irrating passanger sat in your car in a car park going on about how bad her finances are and when I start to fall asleep I just adjust her mirror she soon gets the message! I then kindly rub it in that her car does have electric mirrors but because it is french they have never worked.

Mind you she will soon be rubbing it in that she has a clutch that works and mine dosn't :p.

Resting foot on clutch - captain chaos
I use my electric mirrors when I'm parking so I don't scuff my whitewalls. Those things take ages to clean...
Resting foot on clutch - Rattle
Indeed I have recently primed and resrpayed my wheel trims (a new Vauxhall set costs £40, mine now look as good as new for £10). So I always point the mirror down if I am not sure how close I am to the curb.

I used to think electric mirrors were a pointless gimick until I got them.
Resting foot on clutch - captain chaos
So I always point the
mirror down if I am not sure how close I am to the curb.


This is what you need, Rattle...tinyurl.com/loqpfu :-D
Resting foot on clutch - Stuartli
Rattle, you should curb your gimmicks...:-)

Edited by Stuartli on 04/08/2009 at 01:41

Resting foot on clutch - Lud
I've got electric mirrors now. I still have to look for the control thing and remember how to work it though. I suppose those old-geezer delays will shorten with time.

I use them for parking if I think it's difficult, when I remember. But I am still tending to park this unfamiliar, slightly hulking car a bit further out than I would usually want.

The mirrors park themselves too, a bit untidily on the nearside I notice, at the touch of a button. A tight-space and anti-vandal feature no doubt. I nearly always forget to do it. Or is it that as a rational person I don't bother to remember? (Discuss).

A late friend had the door mirror of his Orion gratuitously and expensively broken by a passing vandal. He felt terribly hurt by it and as an immigrant, let down by the Britain he still sort of half-believed in although he was nobody's fool.
Resting foot on clutch - Rattle
A mirror for my car is £250 but I can get them a lot cheaper from a scrappy.

Lud what car do you have now, I thought you had a battered Escort?
Resting foot on clutch - captain chaos
A mirror for my car is £250 but I can get them a lot cheaper
from a scrappy.

Good grief, Rattle! £250? Is this the article?tinyurl.com/m6rf52
Resting foot on clutch - Rattle
Nope just apparantly what VX charge. Its because of the heated elements inside them. I suspect it would cost about £30-£40 on ebay.
Resting foot on clutch - Lud
what car do you have now, I thought you had a battered Escort?


I still have it. Not all that battered actually. I used a self-tapper to straighten the rear end of the left-hand side of the front bumper and it's more or less straight now for a motor its age, give or take a few coarse patches on the offside sill. It's deeply, to many people who post here sinfully, filthy though and still has the squiggle of gold spray paint it acquired last Christmas while we were in Oz. Drove it last weekend, good as gold, bunged in 20 quid of juice, Ms Lud drove it too, it's OK down the sticks for another six months.

As for the one with electric mirrors, heated leather and suede seats, cruise control, air conditioning, decent sound system, ABS, traction control (I ask you!) and so on, but no proper spare wheel of course in the modern manner, I'm too embarrassed to tell you what it is after all the patronising carp I have given you over the months, which you have taken in good part or anyway in silence... Best to draw a discreet curtain over the whole matter.
Resting foot on clutch - Rattle
So its a Kia or a Rolls Royce then :p.
Resting foot on clutch - Cliff Pope
There seems to be a curious modern definition of "automatic". Apparently it means you have to turn it on, adjust it, then remember to turn it off again.

I have an automatic gearbox. I activate it by pressing the clutch, then tune in whichever of the 5 gears I want to use. Apart from that, it does all the work for me.
Resting foot on clutch - L'escargot
There are some design faults that sound minor but have the capacity to infuriate when
you have to live with them every day and this is one of them I
think.


Whether you see the omission of a footrest as a "design fault" must depend on your personal preference. I've only ever owned one car which had a footrest, and on the basis of that experience I prefer not to have a foot rest. I like my left ankle to be stretched out and you can't do that if your car has a footrest.
Resting foot on clutch - Cliff Pope
A decent car would have an electrically adjustable footrest, which remembers your personal setting when it detects your key.
Resting foot on clutch - Avant
"I'm too embarrassed to tell you what it is...."

I seem to remember that in another thread Lud was honest enough to admit that he'd bought a Chrysler PT Cruiser. Doubtless this was because he got a good deal on it rather than on any aesthetic grounds.

If that isn't true, m'Lud, please accept my apologies and don't sue me for libel. :)
Resting foot on clutch - glowplug
The XM has an electrically adjustable armrest. And, hold on to your hats - it works too!

Steve.
Resting foot on clutch - captain chaos
The Dodge Ram, Ford F150 and a few others have electrically adjustable pedals
Resting foot on clutch - Cliff Pope
The Dodge Ram Ford F150 and a few others have electrically adjustable pedals


Well, there you are then. It's a sign of these decadent, debased times that it is impossible to attempt a satirical joke because reality will overtake the absurdly fantastical almost immediately.
I remember an interview with Michael Wharton (DT Peter Simple) in which he said he was giving up the column because it was impossible to invent satire fast enough now.