Small accident - aggresive response. - max67
I had a really small accident while parking and apologised and left my car reg, name and address and 24 hours later gave my insurance details - really aggressive guy has driven past my house, talked to my children - tore me off a strip while I have apologised several times!

I am now very stressed and can't sleep

Just thought I say, if you have an accident, try to be polite if the other guy is trying to be - I just made a stupid mistake

Edited by Pugugly on 25/09/2008 at 20:52

Small accident - aggresive response. - Blue {P}
Report him to th Police, you've done nothing wrong, in fact, he should think himself lucky that you bothered to give your details.

If I bumped someone I honestly don't think I'd bother to give them my address, a name, number and possibly insurance details is all they really need (yes I know you legally have to provide an address, but really, if they're not with the car they don't have a lot of choice do they?)

Small accident - aggresive response. - Robin Reliant
I've got a split rear bumper, scuffed paint on the front one, a dent in a door and a scratch on the rear wing. Every one was done in a car park while I was away from the vehicle and not one person left a note or hung around to own up. On that basis, should I be idiotic enough to cause damage to a perfectly visible stationary vehicle I'm afraid my attitide would be to say, "Why should I cough up when nobody else ever does?" and drive off.
Small accident - aggresive response. - ForumNeedsModerating
Not a very kind attitude RR. I'm sure we've all had, at some point in our motoring careers, a bump or two with stationary objects. Perhaps the reason you 'attract' all these bumps & scratches is a karmic response to your own intention.

Max67, report the incident, get a Police incident number - always better to have these things logged. You seem to have been unlucky in bumping the car of aggressive, bullying idiot who has no right to talk or interact with anyone except you (without intimidation) - & cetainly not your children.
One thing that I would not tolerate in any way ,shape or form, is anyone (and I mean anyone) attempting to get at me via a family member - they wouldn't be leaving the scene under their own power. Do report this for your own peace of mind.
Small accident - aggresive response. - DP
I agree with woodbines. Straight to the police, and mention that he's been speaking to your kids.

Clearly a very small and rather sad little man with an inferiority complex if he approaches children rather than have a face to face conversation with an adult. It probably tells you all you need to know.

I would lay it on thick to the police about approaching your kids and being concerned for their safety. I'm sure they'll send someone round to have a word with him.

The important thing is, you are completely in the right here, legally and morally.

Edited by DP on 25/09/2008 at 15:57

Small accident - aggresive response. - retgwte
well i gave a twenty quid note in a shop last night, was given change from a tenner, and when i complained was given an agressive load of nonsense, and had my phone taken from me when i went to take a photo of the member of staff

ive had lots of idiots drive into the back of me and just had them shrug their shoulders and written off the repair myself

idiot who caused accident last year was nice enough at the time and gave his details and insurance, but has subsequently denied it to his insurance company

what did he actually do, complain and raise his voice? talking loudly and complaining is not against the law

sounds like you deserve some complaint

so you gave your details great, doesnt at all mean you will own up to your insurance company in this day and age

i intervened to stop some thugs, they nicked my car the following night, support from police to decent citizen, er none

and of course all plod bother with these days is 5 mph over the limit

the country is going to the dogs, get used to it

you tolerate these idiots in power you deserve all you get

Small accident - aggresive response. - Armitage Shanks {p}
Regtwe - you said

"the country is going to the dogs, get used to it
you tolerate these idiots in power you deserve all you get"

I will try to find the quote, exactly, but roughly speaking it said:-

There are 2000 people in positions of real power in this country, there are 2 million people carrying out their edicts and dim regulations, and there are 50 million of us putting up with the carp AND paying their salaries! Remind you of anywhere?

I stand liable for correction of the exact figures but you get the general drift?


Edited by Armitage Shanks {p} on 25/09/2008 at 17:12

Small accident - aggresive response. - harib
An interesting rant - not sure what it's got to do with the OP though...
Small accident - aggresive response. - retgwte
because i have sympathy with the guy going round and complaining loudly

its not as if he has actually done anything physical

admitting the offence and leaving your details does not mean you are innocent

staggers belief

its very hard to put up with the constant barrage of carp nowadays a bit of loud complaint is hardly the biggest problem we have to deal with

Small accident - aggresive response. - GroovyMucker
Anyone smell troll?

Small accident - aggresive response. - harib
Sympathy? Why?

Accidents happen. The OP has fessed up, apologised and done everything by the book. Why the aggrieved party then needs to drive by, talk to his kids and do more loud complaining is beyond me. What's the point? What does it solve? Does it make the insurance claim go quicker or more smoothly? NO. Mr. Angry man may just end up having the police round for his troubles. Fat lot of good complaining loudly did him then.
Small accident - aggresive response. - retgwte
why do you think im a troll?

check out my other posts

so youre not happy with this guys actions, fair enough

getting the police round is a total waste of time since
i) he has done nothing wrong

and

ii) the police do sweet fanny adams even in extreme cases of violence so hoping they are going to somehow help is naive in the extreme

and yes i nearly decked the guy who took my 20 quid note last night, i didnt, but i understand the self control needed to let the pink fluffy dice get away with it, im getting so cheesed off with folk taking the mickey out of ordinary decent folk AND GETTING AWAY WITH IT CONSTANTLY

so yea i understand a little loud complaining, im getting to that point myself

accident happen yes, but normally there is a party at fault

idiots

Edited by Dynamic Dave on 25/09/2008 at 19:59

Small accident - aggresive response. - Lud

accident happen yes but normally there is a party at fault


Yes retgwte. But we can all nerf another car when parking. To leave a note admitting liability and offering, in effect, to make good, is the decent thing to do. To go round and yell at someone who has done that seems the height of unpleasant idiocy, unless of course they have thought better of it and try to welsh. What imaginable good could it do? What purpose is served by being unpleasant to someone who is trying to do the right thing?

Damn nasty shops they have round you. I wouldn't go in that one again.
Small accident - aggresive response. - Pugugly
Without my Mod's hat on.

The reaction of the owner of the damaged car sums up exactly what's wrong with certain elements of soceity, full of mean spirited, nasty little weasels, and exactly why decent, honest people have stopped or are reluctant to do the "right thing".

Stoop to conquer - sort the repair out either by cash or insurance and forget about it, Karma will be along shortly to sort out the little idiot.

In my day to day work I come across people who are on the face of it "normal" who have profoundly at odds ways of handling situations, we've bred a nation of ill-mannered carphounds who lack the social skills that allow them to deal with things that happen to them.
Small accident - aggresive response. - GroovyMucker
why do you think im a troll?


Because I didn't think anyone could seriously be putting forward the views you expressed.

Forgive me: obviously I was wrong.
Small accident - aggresive response. - Group B
i have sympathy with the guy going round and complaining loudly


Why, in this situation does he need to 'go around complaining loudly'? From the information given, the OP has been honest and decent by leaving their details with the damaged car.

Yes the OP is responsible for the damage, but they say they have admitted it and are therefore willing to put it right.
In this situation the other party getting aggressive is totally unnecessary and THAT is an example of this country going to the dogs, IMO.
Small accident - aggresive response. - retgwte
why? he doesnt need a reason

yea so its probably not good manners, but threatening the police and getting all high and mighty is a lot of old tosh

he may have had a bad day

the nhs may be letting his father die for lack of simple treatment

someone may have pranged his car last month, admitted it at the time and been nice as nice can be but susequently denied it to their insurance

his wife may have been beaten up in front of witnesses but the police refused to do anything

there are a whole bunch of reasons he was grumpy

so grumpy people let off steam and complain loudly, i tell you what thats still a lot better than being one of the millions who regularly prang cars at the supermarket cos they are so carp at driving

i think youve all lost your sense of perspective

and to pug im afraid the polite calm and friendly ways of dealing with things tends to lead to you being treated v badly nowadays, im not defending it, i try to be as reasonable as i can myself even under extreme provocation BUT acting like little naive bumkins who phone the police at stuff like this is laughable - for one thing it proves you dont get out much and you dont see the real police priorities out there

and yes we are raising generations in carp schools who know no better BUT there is no reason to suspect this guy was any of the sort

hey scratch my car i may well complain and shout at you, phone the police they will laugh at you, get a life you lot

Small accident - aggresive response. - ifithelps
...get a life you lot...


Small accident - aggressive response - by a poster to a motoring forum.


Edited by ifithelps on 25/09/2008 at 19:42

Small accident - aggresive response. - retgwte
just adding a bit of balance, in a totally non aggressive way

:)

Small accident - aggresive response. - ForumNeedsModerating
What a completely unsympathetic point of view, I can hardly believe it's for real. Well, we create our own world I suppose & perceive it through that prism.
Small accident - aggresive response. - Lud
He may not be a troll as such woodbines but he isn't averse to a bit of barracuda fishing from a motor-boat using a spinner....
Small accident - aggresive response. - retgwte
not really

folk who damage cars, admit it, say sorry, then tell their insurance company they didnt do it create this vibe im afraid

its not unsympathtic, its pragmatic, realism, and based on an understanding of how the other guy feels

Small accident - aggresive response. - gordonbennet
I agree with the majority here, OP doing the right thing, i would be very grateful to find a note with details on my car in the same circumstances, and would make my appreciation known.

Aggressive twerp syndrome seems to be spreading far too quickly.

A lifetime ago my first wife pranged another car on a roundabout, how she described it to me was obvious she was at fault, i called round to see the other driver to offer to pay for his damage, he was so pleasantly surprised, he told me to forget it and we shook hands and parted.....a fast vanishing breed called gentleman.
Small accident - aggresive response. - valmiki
. Perhaps the reason you 'attract'
all these bumps & scratches is a karmic response to your own intention.


that's brilliant! may i borrow that phrase please woodbines, I'm sure that'll come in handy at some point! ;-)
Small accident - aggresive response. - Mapmaker
"go to the police and say he has been talking to your children"

On what planet do you lot live! Only in 2008 Blair's Britain would people regard talking to children as a reason for calling the police.


I have some sympathy for the poor bloke whose car you damaged - he'll need to take time off work, etc. etc. Doesn't excuse his behaving boorishly, but there you are - only in 2008 in Blair's Britain...
Small accident - aggresive response. - retgwte
exactly mapmaker

well said
Small accident - aggresive response. - Lud
Hang on a minute.

How serious is the damage?

Has the OP denied all knowledge of an accident to his insurance company, and refused to make good in other ways? I haven't seen anything like that. What have I missed?
Small accident - aggresive response. - Pugugly
Nothing Lud.
Small accident - aggresive response. - Mapmaker
May I just point out that I do NOT agree with retgwte's approach on this thread. Maybe there is a phrase somewhere with which I might concur, but to be honest I have read a couple of his sentences and my life is too short...

;)
Small accident - aggresive response. - Robin Reliant
And you wonder why people drive off without owning up...
Small accident - aggresive response. - valmiki
blimey, there's some real nutters coming out on this thread

anyone tries to take out their 'bad mood' and intimidate my kids better start running by the time I hear about it.

ans as for the posters saying that the OP deserved everything that he gets - are you so perfect that you've never made a mistake? goodness, at least the man bothered to own up.

would you rather he just drove off?

Edited by Pugugly on 25/09/2008 at 21:53

Small accident - aggresive response. - yorkiebar
I think I would be inclined to "discuss" this guys attitude with him directly. He hasnt contacted the police to complain about being hit (with details left), so why contact the police yet ?

A quiet word first, to see what his problem is/was? Then a bigger word? Perhaps a word more forcibly in his earhole ?

Small accident - aggresive response. - retgwte
turning up at his house for no other reason than to make sure he has given a genuine address is perfectly acceptable in my view

chatting to kids on the drive is perfectly acceptable, no evidence of anything other than friendly banter there

getting a bit upset and loud is understandable within reason

even a minor scratch can mean a day in the bodyshop, day off work for some people if they need the car to get to work, bodyshop maybe miles from their home

there should be some simple way to admit liability at the scene, and things would be a lot calmer for all of us

as it is many folk swap addresses, sound nice and friendly, give false addresses, or subsequently decide to deny they were even there, and its remarkably easy to get away with

escalating to threats is im afraid what u lot are doing

i really dont think im beng nutty here

but hey u talk to the pcso in your leafy suburbs maybe they have nothing to do but nod along with u




Small accident - aggresive response. - valmiki
there should be some simple way to admit liability at the scene and things would
be a lot calmer for all of us


perhaps by using words of less than one syllable? would that be more 'simpler' than what the OP has done?

also, the OP is sorting this all out through his insurance - i'm sure the 'victim' would get a courtesy car for his trouble.

or would you prefer that us less-than-perfect human beings should grovel and beg at your mercy?
Small accident - aggresive response. - retgwte
it really dont work that way

if you get a hire car either youre claiming on your own insurance and taking a no claims hit, or you pay and need to claim (probably only to get paid some months later) from the other parties insurance

and no matter how many syllables the other party uses, and how nice and genuine they sound, it is far from certain they will subsequently put on their insurance claim form what they have admitted at the scene, indeed its far from certain they will even fill in a claim form or admit they were there

i dont expect begging or mercy

but i expect you to understand that its not that simple for the injured party

and the guy who had his car damaged is the injured party here

subsequently getting a bit upset is no big deal, unless it gets threatening or agressive

Small accident - aggresive response. - harib
turning up at his house for no other reason than to make sure he has
given a genuine address is perfectly acceptable in my view
chatting to kids on the drive is perfectly acceptable no evidence of anything other than
friendly banter there
getting a bit upset and loud is understandable within reason


...and this is only for a minor scratch on a car that sounds like it's still perfectly driveable! Lord knows what the reaction would have been if the car was written off! Look, I am of the opinion that you can either catch flies with honey, or with vinegar. Yes, the OP could have given false details, so phone up, go round and double-check.

You see, what's happened now is that maybe the OP is riled up enough to not admit liability now after what's happened. Going in like a bull in a china shop is probably the worst thing this guy has done. If he has had a bad day/week/year, then maybe he needs to not take it out on the wrong people, or he needs a counselling or anger management course.
Small accident - aggresive response. - ForumNeedsModerating
Valmiki - with pleasure!

The contrarian on this thread stands out so much, you might even think he/she was the doppelganger of the OP's protagonist. It does confirm to me that the human mind has an incredible flexibility in its ordering & understanding of phenomena - to the extent that it gives quite a chill merely thinking about whom one might pass on the street.
Small accident - aggresive response. - retgwte
all

i dont go round peoples house when they damage my car

i dont get aggresive with the many and varied idiots who take my money and get away with it

i only really have used controlled agression to defend those i know and love, well within reason as a last resort

i am simply defending this poor guy who may have a nice car, be paying a fortune in car insurance, have been hit by several drivers who have failed to admit their actions to their insurance company etc

i really think there are more than enough real evil criminals out there for you lot to have a pop at before you worry about someone who has just had his property damaged talking to the person who criminally damaged it

you are nutty to start throwing around threats and running this guy down while knowing so little about him

when i was younger i was paying a few grand a year insurance and loved my car, minor damage would have been a major disaster for me

if anything if the system actively acted against the scum who repeatedly get into scrapes and fail to be honest with their insurance companies then a whole lot of good would be done

hey im a big bad monster im sorry your all so blind to putting yourself in the other persons shoes
Small accident - aggresive response. - Sofa Spud
I know someone who 'parks by touch'. She says that's what bumpers are for. Before anyone tells me I'm sexist, I used to know a man who said exactly the same.
Small accident - aggresive response. - Big Bad Dave
That'll be me and Lud.
Small accident - aggresive response. - Bilboman
Forgive my ignorance here - I haven't driven a car in Britain for a long itme - but isn't there a "no fault" three-part pro-forma both parties can fill in and get this all sorted out amicably, which seems to be the original intention here?
The two occasions I've had my car dented, one of us gets out the standard form (comes with the ins document) and I fill in LHS and the other driver fills in RHS (each party has ample space to fill in notes, draw a diagram, etc. and the two versions do not have to agree at all.) Both parties sign it and the form is sent off to the insurance company/companies, who then decide who is at fault; often a simple 50/50 is settled on and the whole process is quite quick: six weeks from original bump till the paint dries.
Regarding the aggrieved driver's aggression: could it be that he doesn't have a valid insurance policy? (Which could in itself invalidate his claim, however legitimate, IIRC...)
Small accident - aggresive response. - jbif
.. i only really have used controlled agression ..


In reply to tetgwte:
I am sorry to say that the comments/views in this thread and your other recent thread
[www.honestjohn.co.uk/forum/post/index.htm?t=67045&...f ] lead me to believe that your view of what qualifies as "controlled agression" is in need of complete readjustment.

I have full sympathy with max67.

Small accident - aggresive response. - v8man
Your views are unbelivable and compounded by your illiteracy!
Small accident - aggresive response. - v8man
My previous post is aimed at retgwte in case of misunderstanding.
Small accident - aggresive response. - Westpig
if I owned up to a small parking dent, which i'm quite liable to do... I would not expect some thug...(OP said "aggressive man, talked to kids and tore me off a strip several times"..) to turn up to my house and give anyone a hard time

anyone who condones that sort of thing, is as bad in my opinion. What's wrong with a bit of civility and courtesy...treat others as you'd expect to be treated yourself.. etc

it's a lack of education and social skills because of previous poor parenting.. and sadly it's getting worse

anyone who thinks they've never made a mistake or had some form of minor accident is delusional......furthermore i'd put money on it the 'agressive man' wouldn't have left a note on someone else's car if he'd damaged it.....which when you put it into perspective would make him a bullying 'low life'.
Small accident - aggresive response. - Big Bad Dave
"treat others as you'd expect to be treated yourself.. etc"

more like treat others as you'd want to be treated yourself.. big difference
Small accident - aggresive response. - paulb {P}
i dont go round peoples house when they damage my car


Quite. Nor should this guy have done.

As I read it, the OP nudged this guy's car and is paying (or his insurers are paying) for the damage caused. The way the guy is carrying on, you'd have thought the OP had beaten up one of his kids and nicked their lunch money.

The key thing here is proportionality and self-control. There was absolutely no need for the guy to behave like that. Having a bad day is no excuse whatsoever.

If it was, after some of the days I have at work sometimes, I would be allowed to behead people on my way home.

I am getting tired of this society that punishes the honest, and the increasing numbers of people who explode into rage if the slightest thing doesn't go their way. My 2-year-old can be excused that up to a point, but not a grown adult.

Edited by paulb {P} on 26/09/2008 at 08:49

Small accident - aggresive response. - L'escargot
I've got a split rear bumper scuffed paint on the front one a dent in
a door and a scratch on the rear wing. Every one was done in a
car park while I was away from the vehicle ...........


Going off at a slight tangent .......

Robin Reliant, what colour car do you have?

I have a theory that dark coloured cars get more carpark dents than bright coloured cars. The reason I buy bright coloured cars is so that they will be more visible to other motorists.
Small accident - aggresive response. - Pugugly
Slight tangent !!!?! :-)
Small accident - aggresive response. - GroovyMucker
Of course, one explanation of the thug's behaviour is that he wasn't insured and the last thing he wants to do is sort things via insurance.