Tesco Parking Enforcement - Armitage Shanks {p}
My local Tesco (Oakham, Rutland) has installed what appear to be ANPR cameras covering the one road into and out of the car park. I suppose that this will automate parking enforcement but will the Penalty Charge income exceed the cost of the system? The parking is certainly popular with people who want to shop at Tesco and walk into the town centre for other shopping.
Tesco Parking Enforcement - L'escargot
A lot of stores and/or retail parks are doing this. The time allowed is usually either 2 or 3 hours ~ more than enough for most genuine shoppers.
--
L\'escargot.
Tesco Parking Enforcement - TheOilBurner
Unless one happens to use the (often) on-site Tescos cafe, feeds and changes a baby and then shops?

I always felt the systems that gave free parking on demonstration of a till receipt worked best. Even if someone is taking the mickey by using the parking for town, they've at least come and spent a minimum amount (5/10 quid usually to get free parking), better than hounding otherwise decent customers?
Tesco Parking Enforcement - Stuartli
Unless one happens to use the (often) on-site Tescos cafe, feeds and changes a baby and then shops?>>


We have one of the largest and busiest Tesco Extra stores in the UK less than two miles from where I live - it now has a "three hour" parking limit policy (hardly surprising in view of its abuse by some motorists who work nearby).

I could use the cafe, feed and change nappies for a couple of young babies and fit in the shopping in far less than three hours and with plenty of time to spare...:-)

That's even with being out of practice, with regard to the offspring, for several decades...:-)


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
What\'s for you won\'t pass you by
Tesco Parking Enforcement - pmh
I have one friend who was hounded (on his death bed) by the debt collectors from Tescos about a perceived overstay. It was actually 2 separate visits of his car, with the manual system unable to differentiate between separate parking periods. It took over 4 months of letters and visits to the store manager by SIL to get the dogs called off. He was dead by then!

At least an ANPR system will overcome this. Whether it will read mis-spaced plates and funny fonts is another issue. Time for flaps on the number plates I guess for arrival and departure at the supermarket car park and then free all day parking again for the commuters!

.


--

pmh (was peter)


Tesco Parking Enforcement - L'escargot
Unless one happens to use the (often) on-site Tescos cafe, feeds
and changes a baby and then shops?


Well, I did say more than enough for most genuine shoppers.

--
L\'escargot.
Tesco Parking Enforcement - Armitage Shanks {p}
I went to Tesco to change my babtybut I didn't like their selection so I took the original one home! Merry Christmas all!
Tesco Parking Enforcement - Dwight Van Driver
Examine the small print of the parking arrangement pmh.

'No retun in "X" hours.

Camera will spot in and out twice within the period and you get a ticket because the parking time in total has been exceeded.

Also bear in mind it is the intention of HMG to have all these cameras geared to National data base of ANPR......

dvd
Tesco Parking Enforcement - rtj70
We have a local Tesco Express with parking restrictions. Problems with parking do exist but some of the cars taking the spaces are staff... hmm.

What I think could anger real customers, like me, is you pop to the shop and get some things. You get home later realise you forgot something and go back. So in theory because I go back I could be fined £70 (the time limit is 30 minutes I think)... I suppose Tesco Clubcard might come in handy proving two separate shopping visits. The alternative is you shop somewhere else.
Tesco Parking Enforcement - Mad Maxy
You'll find that the parking rules are enforced by some dodgy third party that couldn't give a fig for about your two till receipts...
Tesco Parking Enforcement - rtj70
"You'll find that the parking rules are enforced by some dodgy third party that couldn't give a fig for about your two till receipts..."

Exactly... so they might end up keeping loyal customers away.
Tesco Parking Enforcement - Stuartli
It's still better than risking a parking ticket from the local council's draconian traffic wardens if you go to Asda - the council has the parking rights....:-(

Which is one reason why I don't shop at Asda. All to easy to overlook the time if you pay for half-an-hour in advance and have to wait to pay at the checkouts.

In fairness to Asda it does refund parking charges if you spend a certain amount or more, but it can't be much good for its profits.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
What\'s for you won\'t pass you by
Tesco Parking Enforcement - Vansboy
There's been complaints to our BBC 3 Counties Radio consumer prog, recently, about the fuel station at Stanstead Airport - not naming/shaming in case there are more than one.

Apparently a fixed penalty is mailed to you if you outstay their 20 minute allowable time frame. So how anyone would fuel, feed, coffee, kiddies clean up & impulse buy, goodness knows!!

The problem was 'created' by passengers being dropped off on the site, rather than proper set down/pick up points. No doubt other Broomers, familiar with the location will let us know how practical this would be!

VB
Tesco Parking Enforcement - Simon
I saw a similar system to this being used at the Somerfield store in Borrowash nr Derby. Basically Borrowash is a village which happens to have a medium sized Somerfield store but very few other shops nearby, with the exception of a couple of hairdressers, a butchers, a florist, a small hardware store, a travel agent, a wedding dress shop, an angling shop, a chemist and a pet shop. Not much else around other than private housing and certainly not somewhere you would park for hours and hours.

Anyway, one day they decided to install this ANPR business on the entrances to the car park and set a time limit for the use of the car park. Everyone was up in arms about it and the system was only live for two or three weeks. So what observations did I make? Well before the ANPR I can never remember seeing any parking problems in the day time. There were always spaces and it was never chock a block. As soon as the ANPR appeared a lot of cars disappeared, which left the car park almost deserted (comparitively). I understand that the other businesses were hit by a sudden drop in trade and they led the protests against Somerfield. Presumably no one wanted to risk parking there whilst going for a haircut etc, and took their trade elsewhere. Whether or not the parking restrictions hit Somerfield themselves I don't know.

So like I say the ANPR parking scheme ceased after a few weeks and has never been reintroduced. The state of play in the car park is back to what it was, and personally I can't see any problem with that whatsoever. I can only conclude that the car parking scheme was primarily designed to extract money from people, rather than to combat any parking problems.
Tesco Parking Enforcement - rustbucket
>>Apparently a fixed penalty is mailed to you if you outstay their 20 minute allowable time frame. So how anyone would fuel, feed, coffee, kiddies clean up & impulse buy, goodness knows!!
The same thing is happening at BP /McDonalds at Gatwick
another money maker and no appeal I know a couple of people been caught and they were genuine visitors to McDonalds.Its about time we English stood up to this type of thing, these bullies can only get away with it in Britain be ause we are so soft and week and are mug enough to put up with it

--
rustbucket (the original)
Tesco Parking Enforcement - pmh
DVD

The thinking behind the the 'no return clause' is to allow 'policing' by low tech manual methods, ie a man making a list which only records presence at a given point in time. Not location, and 2 records more than X hours apart are assumed to mean that the vehicle has been there all the time. This is to prevent all day parking or overstays.

However once ANPR is implemented (on enter and leave) they can detect muti entries and length of stay. They then do not need to a have a no return policy. Provided of course that they can correctly identify the vehicle registration plate! They will need to have a time limit posted of course so that they can enforce the charges on the overtays, and to catch manually (probably on an a random basis those who conceal the registration plates.

Question, is it an offence to conceal the number plate in a private car park? I presume it is private since they can enforce their own charging regime!
--

pmh (was peter)


Tesco Parking Enforcement - Micky
I would be surprised if the document issued by Tesco (or agents) is a Penalty Charge, I doubt if it's a Parking Ticket. It probably relates to a contract that Tesco (or agents) claim the driver enters into when parking at Tesco. So, how do Tesco (or agent) enforce the contract? By writing to the registered keeper perhaps? Why should the registered keeper respond? Which piece of legislation requires the registered keeper to tell Tesco (or agent) who the driver was at the time the car was parked in Tesco?

It's unenforceable, as are most contracts concerning parking. Wheel clamping is a different animal, the advantage lies with the clamper, the clampee is usually on the backfoot ... and on foot generally.

But, if it means more space for me in Tescos car park then so be it ;-) Now, why would I go to Tesco? I enjoy their delivery service but to enter one of their stores must be purgatory.
Tesco Parking Enforcement - Pugugly {P}
"Now, why would I go to Tesco? I enjoy their delivery service but to enter one of their stores must be purgatory"

Now when I asked that question in another thread (as to why my wife goes when we live within range of two home delivery equipped stores) Big Bad Dave said it was due to the Sexual Chemistry she encounters there.....................I go there 'cos I need to eat - simple !
Tesco Parking Enforcement - Micky
You eat at Tesco? That must be awful. Can't you afford a decent restaurant?

Perhaps your wife feels the need to escape the confines of Pugtowers on occasions? Just a thought!
Tesco Parking Enforcement - Pugugly {P}
I never thought of that. Maybe that's why end up there. I ate at Tesco once between appointments......not good.
Tesco Parking Enforcement - Nsar
I posted here in the summer about an annoying twerp who took great delight in telling me I'd be getting a fine of £100 for loading on a double yellow in the middle of the night at Liverpool Airport. He told me the cameras had got my plate and "they'll get you that way".
I recalled a day or two later that the DVLA have my name very slightly wrong on their database so any letters to that spelling but not from DVLA are going to get returned "not known at this address". Am I going to tell the DVLA?
Tesco Parking Enforcement - Stuartli
The crux of the matter is that Tesco isn't going to come down like a ton of brick on genuine shoppers, only those that take advantage of the free parking space it provides at somewhat considerable expense to itself i.e those that might work in the area and leave their vehicles on its car park all day.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
What\'s for you won\'t pass you by
Tesco Parking Enforcement - rustbucket
>>I would be surprised if the document issued by Tesco (or agents) is a Penalty Charge, I doubt if it's a Parking Ticket. It probably relates to a contract that Tesco (or agents) claim the driver enters into when parking at Tesco. So, how do Tesco (or agent) enforce the contract? By writing to the registered keeper perhaps? Why should the registered keeper respond? Which piece of legislation requires the registered keeper to tell Tesco (or agent) who the driver was at the time the car was parked in Tesco?


This is probably true but if you drive a lease /hire car the lease / hire company may well pay the fine and then recoupe the sum via a credit card or bill the user. when the lease / hire company do this they usually add a very large administratve charge.This has happened to collegues of mine with company vehicle including visitors from overseas.
--
rustbucket (the original)
Tesco Parking Enforcement - Micky
">hire company may well pay the fine<"

It's a not fine, Tesco (or agents) want you to think it's a fine, probably for a criminal act.

If there is a contract in place then it's between Tesco (or agents) and the driver, any payment from the hire/lease company to Tesco is outside of the contractual agreement, take it up with the credit card company. As always, it depends how much effort the driver is prepared to go to.

forums.pepipoo.com/index.php?showforum=30
Tesco Parking Enforcement - rustbucket
>>It's a not fine, Tesco (or agents) want you to think it's a fine, probably for a criminal act.


Fine or not hire / lease company still pay it and levy a hefty charge for admin and bill you the driver or company, result is you are left in a complicated tangle of debt.
--
rustbucket (the original)
Tesco Parking Enforcement - Pugugly {P}
What makes me laugh in one town nearby is that a Tesco was built in the town. Parking is controlled there with plenty of signage and visible enforcement. The layout of the car park is poor with cramped turning arcs and narrow bays. We always park on the main road directly opposite, there are no restrictions at all there and have never failed to find a spot, it adds an extra 60 feet to your walk from the store to this point - people are conditioned to drive in to this cramped area and miss the obvious - either that or lazy.
Tesco Parking Enforcement - Micky
There is a world of difference between a fine and an invoice. And the document issued by Tesco(or agents) is not a fine

">you are left in a complicated tangle of debt.<"

Not really, it's fairly simple. The contract that Tesco (or agents) attempt to enforce is with the driver, not the hire/lease company. In fact, it has nothing to do with the registered keeper, Tesco (or agents) might write to the RK, but there is no legal requirement for the RK to respond.

However, I can forsee a situation where the hire/lease company receives the "Notice of Fine" or "Penalty Charge Notice" or whatever the document is described as and assumes that it is a fine that can be legally enforced. Ask the hire/lease company "Why have you paid this invoice for me?" Because that's what it is, an invoice.

Isn't the personal data held by hire/lease companies protected by some legislation? Or can they distribute it to anyone who sends them an invoice?

Alternatively, just give up and pay them.
Tesco Parking Enforcement - rustbucket
Isn't the personal data held by hire/lease companies protected by some legislation? Or can they distribute it to anyone who sends them an invoice?

Yes it probably is ,but what happens is hire /lease company recieve "invoice" , "fine"or PNC pass this paperwork onto company or driver who has hired / leased vehicle if no payment is made or responded to then hire / lease company pay up on your behalf and then bill you plus admin charge for their part in it.This is certainly written into the very very small print of several lease contracts I have seen.So no personell information is released by the hire / lease company.

The agent or Tesco or whoever can only obtain details of registered owner through DVLA so can only deal with the hire / lease company so like a speeding fine ect can take up to 2 yes 2 months to reach the driver.This situation is covered in the Police notice of prosecution so the 14 day rule for get out is not applicable to company vehicle / hire / lease drivers for proper convictions.

--
rustbucket (the original)
Tesco Parking Enforcement - Micky
">This is certainly written into the very very small print of several lease contracts I have seen<"

Probably for criminal/decriminalised parking, I'd be surprised if the terms and conditions referred to paying an invoice on behalf of a hirer. The lease company should redirect to the hirer in case the invoice is invalid. I must check next time.

">or responded to<"

Ah, well there's an easy answer there, if you want to respond, write back to the scamsters:

"I deny any agreement to pay this unlawful charge" or similar.



Tesco Parking Enforcement - rustbucket
this link is interesting re parking tickets ect


www.consumeractiongroup.co.uk/forum/parking-traffi...l

--
rustbucket (the original)
Tesco Parking Enforcement - The Lawman
Are you a lawyer Micky?

If not then you should be, your take on this is absolutely spot on.
Tesco Parking Enforcement - Micky
">Are you a lawyer Micky?<"

Yes, I am a well known lawyer .. a barrack room lawyer ;-)
Tesco Parking Enforcement - Cribbage Crisis
I still want to know under which piece of legislation can a third-party company get access to my DVLA details so that they can send bills, invoices, fines or whatever to my address.

Isn't it part of the Data Protection Act that these details cannot be passed on or used by other companies without my permission and I don't recall doing that.
Tesco Parking Enforcement - Dalglish
I still want to know under which piece of legislation can a third-party company get access to my DVLA details

>>

read all about it here:
www.dvla.gov.uk/foi/relinfo.aspx

Tesco Parking Enforcement - Navara Van man
My local tesco have now done this. Good tip about covering the number plates!

Tesco Parking Enforcement - Dwight Van Driver
>>>>>>> I still want to know under which piece of legislation can a third-party company get access to my DVLA details so that they can send bills, invoices, fines or whatever to my address.<<<<<<<<<

.....enter stage left ...........clears throat.....

My Lords, Ladies hend Gentlemen

It is Regulation 27 Road Vehicles (Registration and Licensing) Regulations, 2002 also known as S.I. 2742 of 2002.

..bows....... exits right to standing ovation..

dvd

Tesco Parking Enforcement - sierraman
If you live in Leeds and visit Maplins or the Arndale Centre in Headingley watch out for a man in a yellow van,he deals out tickets.I've seen him photographing a car he had done for parking incorrectly i.e.a wheel on the white line.They tried to enforce parking on a piece of waste ground in Headingley but people got round it by ripping the signs down.Then they put in a ticket machine but that was sabotaged,so now they have earthed up the entrances.
Tesco Parking Enforcement - pmh
DVD

my ealier reply got lost in the threaded reply, but one simple question

Question, is it an offence to conceal the number plate in a private car park? I presume it is private since they can enforce their own charging regime!

Ok, it maybe that the car park small print covers this issue, but you probably cannot read the small print until you entered the car park!


--

pmh (was peter)


Tesco Parking Enforcement - Armitage Shanks {p}
DVD. Many thanks for your relevant and pertinent comments throughout the year. Please continue to inform and advise us in 2007! Best Wishes AS
Tesco Parking Enforcement - autumnboy
The same applies to Sainsbury's car park at the Cwmbran store, where this is looked after on the behalf by Euro Car Parks.

Max stay 2.00hrs and not to return within 2.00hrs. Must park within white lines or you get a £50 penalty.




Tesco Parking Enforcement - daveyjp
On the busiest Friday of the year our local Waitrose parking attendent was happily ticketing any car which was there for longer than two hours. He also ticketed a smart, which whilst not in a bay was in a 'smart' sized are of land not causing anyone any inconvenience. Seeing the chaos the manager told us to park in the 'pick up only - max stay 15 minutes' bay. I told him about the parking attendent and he immediately went and told him to cancel the tickets as it wasn't the best idea to rub shoppers up the wrong way. We were in the store just shy of two hours - queuing to pay took half of this time. No ticket on our car either so the manager's word worked.
Tesco Parking Enforcement - Micky
">you get a £50 penalty<"

It's not a penalty, it's an invoice (have I said that before?)