thanks but I am not sure that answers my question. Maybe I posted it badly. I wasn't planning to supply the clutch pack just asking if any were better than others.

there are no nasty vibrations or juddering so what is the likelyhood? thanks

Main dealer @ £680 isn't a bad price at all, i doubt you'll get much better at an indy.

Even daughter's petrol Civic clutch was a pricey affair, some £450 at an indy as i recall, not the easiest job in the world, and having fitted a new clutch with my lad in his Subaru with the extra weight of transfer box plus extra prop to unbolt due to AWD, the job was hard and heavy.

LUK is another good clutch make, not sure what OE make would be via the main dealer, but unless there at least £150 difference in it and that at a very well regarded indy, i would be letting the dealer do the job.

To compare costs, other daughter's Aygo needed new clutch, dealer quoted some £750, we got it done at th excellent indy in the town for £280 all incl, with them supplying LUK clutch.

LUK clutches and DMFs are excellent quality and OE supply to some makes.

As an example had the clutch and DMF replaced on my 2008 Ford S Max 2.0 TDCi a few weeks ago. Main dealer (South Somerset) £1100 all in, local reputable specialist using LUK parts £700 all in.

I suspect you could save about 30 to 40% by using an indi rather than the dealer.

And definitely replace the DMF, false economy not too.

Edited by Ian D on 02/07/2018 at 21:56