Changing road springs - corax

So your dampers are past their best, and they're either leaking or not controlling the springs very well.

In the past I've changed dampers and kept the original springs. They were keeping the car at the right height and not showing signs of fatigue.

Do springs have to be changed at the same time as dampers when renewing? I could understand it if the springs were prone to breakage, as many of them seem to be poorer quality these days, but is this always the case?

Just interested in peoples thoughts.

Changing road springs - SLO76
Seems to be mainly European cars that suffer such commonplace spring failure. I've replaced several in recent years on Vauxhalls, Fords and BMW in particular, one only 4 1/2 years old! But I've never had to replace a spring on a Japanese motor to date and that includes the largely Jap older runabouts I keep for my work, currently an 11yr old Mazda 3.
Changing road springs - bathtub tom

I had to replace a spring on a 2003 Nissan Almera when it was around eight years old. Could that have been a European, Sunderland one?

Changing road springs - Wackyracer

A few of the suspension manufacturers recommend changing the spring and shock absorber at the same time. One well known manufacturer recommends inspection every 30000kms and replacing them at 80000kms.

Having said that, I have changed broken springs and kept the original shocks as they had only done about 13,000miles. On another car recently, I kept the original 100,000mile springs and just replaced the shocks as the springs were perfect to look at and the wire thickness was a heavy gauge (unlike modern cars).

Edited by Wackyracer on 19/11/2016 at 12:16

Changing road springs - RT

It's not a standard recommendation to replace springs when you replace the dampers - but - they will have done the same duty and some are very prone to breakage on speed humps.

Changing road springs - gordonbennet

I've only ever changed springs after breakage, or weakening leading to losing ride height, the latter more the realm of leaf springs.

Interesting about the Japanese springs, i too have never changed one but have known older abused Mitsi pick ups to break their leaves, coils seem to last forever.

Changing road springs - corax

I had a broken rear spring on my BMW 3 series. Very common apparently. The car was leaning slightly, but the breakage couldn't be seen until the spring was removed.

I've never known a Japanese spring to break, although I'm sure that with enough pothole abuse they will!

Changing road springs - twitcherman

Have had to replace both rear springs on my Prius due to breakage. I think coil springs are fragile across the board nowadays.

Changing road springs - hillman

I was told that the springs are not now plated to prevent pollution to the environment and instead coated with plastics. When the plastics harden and road water gets through to the spring corrosion begins and that is the start of a crack that spreads through the spring. Oh, and some drivers ignore speed humps and go across them at speed.

I have a collection of spring fragments that I've picked up from the roadside. Rather pick them up with my hands than the car's tyres.

Changing road springs - RaineMan

In my first twenty years of driving I only ever had one set of leaf springs overhauled but the car was over thirty years old at the time. Until recently I have run Vauxhalls and since the millenium have suffered broken srings on a Carlton, a Calibra and an Omega. And I slow down for speed humps! It does seem the newer the car the lower the mileage when a spring fails!

Changing road springs - martint123

I swapped all springs on my old MX5 after one front and one rear went in a couple of weeks. Breakages were one turn up where the spring passed over the end of the coil.

There were rumours of a bad batch of springs circa 1990