parking charge from The Range - not paying! - bananastand

RIDDLE ME THIS. There is a branch of "The Range" in St Helens, Lancashire, which used to be a Tesco and has a very big car park. It has been abused by shoppers lately and especially by people leaving their cars there all day when they go to work, or just to avoid the ludicrous parking restrictions in the town. Anyway, two or three weeks ago it was my last day before going on my hols and I was wizzing round the shops, and my list did include stuff from Range, but in truth I forgot to go in. The car was parked about 45 minutes, but let's say for the sake of argument it was over one hour.

I had heard rumours of some "lads" in a white van parked up there watching for people taking advantage, but I found out for myself when I noticed a parking charge notice on the windscreen. They had craftily and carefully placed it over the tax disc so I didn't notice it straight away. I guess the reasoning was that if I HAD seen it I would have gone in the shop and therefore not be a car park "abuser", as the notices do say you are allowed 2 hours parking. I will swear on a stack of bibles that I was not there anywhere near that length of time.

The shop's staff always ask customers whether they intend to stay longer than two hours, incidentally.

The charge's wrapper looks all "official" and scary with policey-type chequering round the edge. It says "it is an offence for any person other than the driver to remove this notice".

The notice itself just says I was in contravention, but is no more specific than that.

And careparking.co.uk now reckon I owe £100 which will increase if I let it go over 28 days.

THE QUESTIONS:

Is it really an offence, ie against the law, for anyone to remove the notice?

In court, will they base their charge on my not shopping there, or will they lie and say I was there more than 2 hours?

Do they earn their money from scaredy-cats just paying up, or will they find it worth their while to fight me in court now that the law has been changed in their favour, as Honest John has recently reported?

Thanks chaps.

One final thing, if you are one of those bores who thinks I should pay because I broke the terms of the implied contract, please don't waste the precious moments God has granted us on this earth by letting me know. FANX.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - bananastand

I remember HJ used to advise that you should offer them £5 or £10 in full settlement.

By the way I forgot to say that the car park was about half-full, so I was not depriving the shop of any potential custom. I've written to the Range to say what I think of them, although I do know that "Care Parking" is a separate entity. OR IS IT.....?

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - skidpan

One final thing, if you are one of those bores who thinks I should pay because I broke the terms of the implied contract, please don't waste the precious moments God has granted us on this earth by letting me know

There is another phrase that describes the people you appear to despise. Law Abiding Citizens.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - bananastand

Really, what law did I break, pray?

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - skidpan

There will be a sign informing you that the car park is for the benefit of customers using whatever store it is. There are plenty where I live that display these signs. If you park there and don't use the store you are breaking this condition thus you should have to pay whatever fine is displayed on the same board.

Basically i have no sympathy, if you cannot be bothered to park legally you should pay the fine. Perhaps it would better if they simply towed cars away and charged for their return.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - bananastand

You don't get it Skid old man. I did park legally, as i didn't break the law. I haven't been "fined".

Up until now I have been a loyal Range customer.

And finally - they put the charge on my windscreen inside one hour of my parking there. THEY HAD NO IDEA OF WHETHER I WAS GOING TO SHOP IN THERE OR NOT. They put the charge on the tax disc presumably in an attempt to stop me seeing it. I'm guessing, but if I had gone in, they would have taken the opportunity to remove it again.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - skidpan

You are allowed to park 2 hours if you use the shop. You admit you did not use the shop thus broke the T & C's.

Car parks near us (with T & C's like to near you parked in) have staff watching for people who park, visit the shop (Halfords as an example) and then walk off site to continue their shopping elsewhere. They get a ticket on their car when they return, bet they only do it once.

Other shops (ASDA as an example) charge £1 for 2 hours and you can shop wherever you like. If you visit ASDA and actually spend some money they give you the £1 coin back.

Car parks actually cost the shops. They have to maintain them and buy the land in the first place. Why should people be allowed to abuse the T & C's when they want to shop elsewhere.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - bananastand

I see you have realised the errors contained in your previous postings.

Even allowing for the contract that allows me 2 hours parking, the charge notice was placed on the car during the first hour. I am sure that if I had gone in the shop, the "lads" would have removed it. The Range can hardly want customers bringing products straight back in screaming their heads off.

There is now a facebook page devoted to this incident, if you want to be bothered looking for it!

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - skidpan

I see you have realised the errors contained in your previous postings.

I have not changed a thing from my previous postings. My opinion is you should obey the T &C's or be prepared to pay the fine.

Is that celar enough.

As for creating a Facebook page devoted to an incident where YOU broke the rules it amazes me how sad people are.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - bananastand

You told me I should obey the law. I haven't broken any law. You keep talking of fines. I have not been fined. These are important distinctions. £100 is excessive and I call it gouging, because the charge is dressed up to look like a fine and some people will be scared into paying it.

I repeat I was parked less than one hour and I believe that if I'd gone in the shop they would have removed it.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - daveyjp
Forget the mitigating circumstances, you are now the victim of an attempted gouge. appeal along the lines of advice from moneysavingexpert and parkingprankster and all will be well.
parking charge from The Range - not paying! - a303

There's a retail park near me which has a large car park. I used to park there to do my shopping - some of which was done at the retail and some at other shops a short walk away. I always assumed I was safe from getting a ticket as I was a customer at the retail park.

However, I noticed recently that the signs specify that one of the conditions of parking there is that you cannot leave the retail park whilst your car is parked. I've wondered about the "human rights" impact of such a restriction (!), but now I just park (and shop) elsewhere.

I wonder if the T&Cs at your car park are similar?

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - skidpan

However, I noticed recently that the signs specify that one of the conditions of parking there is that you cannot leave the retail park whilst your car is parked. I've wondered about the "human rights" impact of such a restriction

I have never read such a stupid comment in my entire life. What has "human rights" got to do with car parking.

People should simply park legally or pay up if they get caught and stop moaning.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - Hamsafar

Are you crazy skidpan? If I wear a T-shirt that says The charge for frowing at me is £100, would you pay if I said you frowned? He did park legally from what he/she has said - it is wrong of you to infer otherwise.

Edited by Hamsafar on 29/04/2014 at 20:19

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - bananastand

Skid will you PLEASE try and understand that I have not broken the law. What is this "parking legally" business?

And thanks chaps I'd forgotten about moneysavingexpert.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - bananastand

Skid will you PLEASE try and understand that I have not broken the law. What is this "parking legally" business?

And thanks chaps I'd forgotten about moneysavingexpert.

about 9 or 10 years ago HJ reported on some firm operating on an industrial estate that had quite a big entrance. People would use it for turning round. They put some dweeb in a hi-viz there with some kind of camera or registration recognition thingy, and anyone who turned got sent a "fine" (okay Skidpan?) for trespass. They complied with the "law" (Skid?) by having a wee notice up on the fence. Silly I know but because it looked all official and policey with B&W checks down the side, it was worth it, because some were daft enough to pay.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - bazza

We have had this several times in our family and we've researched it well. A well known local burger joint use a private company -or at least used to and then tried to sting you for an overstay- some silly amount. If I recall the legal position is something along the lines of ( I'm not a legal begal so this is from memory of reading up on it):-

When you park you - personally- as the driver enter into a contract with the car parking peeps.The T&C would be displayed somewhere. So if you break them they can in theory come after you. The problem being that they would have to prove in court that it was you driving and not someone else driving your car. Difficult. Secondly - as far as I remember- they could only claim reasonable losses from you and £100 would not be reasonable loss. Indeed, their appears to be no loss to them at all, so what can they claim? Nothing.

It's something like that. Plenty of info if you google..... My neighbour is an ex police chief inspector and he has defined it as similar to above, ignores the letters and isn't worried one jot.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - bananastand

Thanks Bazza, I personally know people who have had these charges in the same car park and paid up in a shot. They just somehow think they "have to".

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - alan1302

Are you crazy skidpan? If I wear a T-shirt that says The charge for frowing at me is £100, would you pay if I said you frowned? He did park legally from what he/she has said - it is wrong of you to infer otherwise.

If you go on private land you obey their rules - by using the car park you agree to thir terms and conditions.

Edited by alan1302 on 29/04/2014 at 21:49

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - Smileyman

It's private land ... the owner has prepapred it in a nice inviting way for you to park your car so to make it convenient for you to visit their shop for the purpose of shopping and then when you are finished shopping (and perhaps had a nice cup of tea in their restuarant, used the loos etc) to drive away

not to use as a local car park for the convenience fo visiting other stores or for that matter any other purpose

they tell you this and remind you that they will impose a charge if certain conditions are met / not met, including a 'discount' for prompt payment of that charge

the fee will be a civil contractural matter, not criminal, although they may be permitted to obtain your details from DVLA

I guess if you don't pay or dispute the matter they might commence action in a county court, if you loose there will be court fees, bailiffs fees etc to pay.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - bazza

That's a pretty good summary too. Where the whole thing becomes less clear is proving who the person making the agreeement contractually is. e.g my car is driven by many people, all of whom could be the person breaching the T&C here. Of course I am the registered keeper so the letter will come to me, but there is no proof I was the one using the car park.

And even if i can be proven to be the correct person to take action against , then the whole issue of what losses I have caused and what are reasonable losses to claim off me is another grey area! e.g if I had lost the Car Park company some parking fees, then those would be reasonable to claim off me. Hence the likelihood of court action is low as the case is so weak.- as far as I can remember from reading up on this.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - Armitage Shanks {p}

A recent court action prtoduced the following result. Firm ABC owned a shop and car park, 2 hours free and then a penalty, with correct signage. They delegated control and enforcement to XYZ parking. It turned out that, while they had given control to XYZ they had failed to give them authority to collects the penalties. thus unenforecable.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - Avant

"I''ve written to the Range to say what I think of them."

If you've written politely and apologetically for parking in their customers' car park and not going into their shop, you have a good chance of their withdrawing the charge, as presumably they will want you to shop there again.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - Snakey

Sorry, but these car parking bunch are crooks pure and simple. Parking is never an 'offence' and they just out to milk it for anything they think they can get away with.

Wouldn't bother with the range again either.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - skidpan

Parking is never an 'offence'

Can I come and park across the front of your drive then if that's the case, possibly even park on your drive.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - daveyjp
Strawman argument. The police will quite happily shift a vehcile which is causing an obstruction on the highway or on a drive.

This is about the fundamental issue of one person penalising another. In UK law, unless penalites are openly agreed between both parties the charges cannot stand.

Argue all you like about morality, the parking companies have none, just like the clampers had none and looked what happened to them, they all became parking company operatives.

I would also warn those who say park within the rules and you won't get an invoice not to grow the Angel wings too quickly. I picked one up because an ANPR system wasn't working correctly. They pursued, I won, but I knew what i was doing, many others would have been conned out of the cash.
parking charge from The Range - not paying! - cilvilservant

It's not an offence to park in other peoples drives.

Nor has the OP done anything illegal. Chill out skidpan.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - Gibbo_Wirral

Sorry, but these car parking bunch are crooks pure and simple

I've never seen the need for such hate against them, just like with traffic wardens. They're doing their job so I can drive and park easier.

It would be good to find out figures of how many people get caught, I'd put money on it being a minority, and they're just bawling and making the most noise because they've been caught out - they're usually the ones who get defensive and start attacking you when you ask if you saw the big signs at the entrance and around the car parks.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - thunderbird

All these threads about parking fines are beyond belief.

There is a simple solution:

ONLY PARK WHERE ITS PERMITTED AND FOR THE TIME PERMITTED.

Strange as it might appear if you follow that simple rule you never get a Penalty Notice, parking Ticket or whatever you wish to call them.

If you do get a ticket rather than calling the people who provide the car parks and their staff "crooks" consider that if you had followed the T & C's that are displayed you would not have a ticket.

By not paying or leaving the car park its the user that is the "crook".

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - jamie745

Sod em.

If it's not from the council or the rozzers, just ignore it. See if they can be bothered to take you to court for this heinous offence. Maybe it'll get it's own episode of Law & Order.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - skidpan

Chill out skidpan

I am quite chilled thank you. That is because I don't park where I shouldn't. If I did not do as the notices in car parks required I would have reason to worry but as things are at present I am quite relaxed.

Take our office car park. There are big signs saying its for use by staff only displaying permits. There have been the odd occation when visitors have been ticketed before they have had the opportunity to get back with a permit. never been an issue, the company who look after the car park simply tear up the ticket. When shoppers decide to use it as a free car park instead of using the adjacent council Pay and Display car park and then get tickets it makes us all laugh heartilly, serves the b*****s right.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - jamie745

Problem is most people don't actually know they're not obligated to respond if it's not from the council or the police. These parking companies you pay fortunes for can't actually do anything at all - especially now the Government's banned clamping in England. Most of the car park charge goes to fund the useless people who 'manage' the car park.

If they start resurfacing them, I'll pay them.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - skidpan

Problem is most people don't actually know they're not obligated to respond if it's not from the council or the police. These parking companies you pay fortunes for can't actually do anything at all - especially now the Government's banned clamping in England. Most of the car park charge goes to fund the useless people who 'manage' the car park.

If they start resurfacing them, I'll pay them.

So from that we must assume you never pay for parking.

What does get me angry is when I have paid and parked legally some scum of the earth don't pay or walk off and then start talking about human rights and other totally irrelevent bull s***.

Make it a capitol offence and hang them. That would stop then whining

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - jamie745

Honestly? I rarely pay to park anywhere, and I view yellow lines as advisory.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - RickyBoy

Ditto – except for somewhere like (as I've mentioned before) 'coastal Cornwall' where they've got you by the chaps!

I'd rather walk a mile or so (having sought out somewhere where I can park for free all day) into said town or city. Places I knowfor sure where I can't do that I just don't visit – Laaarnden, obviously.

Anyway, that's nothing...

..a couple of Thursday's ago RickyGirl (daughter) popped her head in the door and said 'is it OK for P**** to leave her motor on the drive overnight, she'll collect it in the morning'. 'For sure' was my reply.

Unbeknown to me/us(!) P**** spontaneously(?) went to Spain on the Friday – for 6-days – leaving her Mazda softop and no keys behind!!!

Long story short, RickyGirl became increasingly embarrassed about the whole issue as time went by and I, to put it mildly, wasn't too impressed.

After deliberating whether I was going to torch, tow or sell it it was collected, rather sheepishly, in the dead of night (to avoid any anticipated confrontation from moi :–)) by either said P**** or her parents/brother/sister/lodger/cat...

Kids, eh...

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - Andrew-T

Honestly? I rarely pay to park anywhere, and I view yellow lines as advisory.

That's a nice 'sod-you' attitude. If you park on a 'thoroughfare' (i.e.a public road, whose main function is to provide a way from A to B, not a place to dump a stationary vehicle) you are helping to obstruct it. So those who are obstructed can hope that you might be prevented from doing it.

If you park on privately-owned land (e.g.a supermarket car-park) you should expect to comply with the requirements of the owners, which may be that you become a customer of theirs. Of course if you can get away without paying, that's fine, but please don't claim that you have been unfairly victimised if you get caught and penalised.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - galileo

What does get me angry is when I have paid and parked legally some scum of the earth don't pay or walk off and then start talking about human rights and other totally irrelevent bull s***.

Make it a capitol offence and hang them. That would stop then whining

On two occasions in recent months TGBs (sorry, 'travellers' ) have parked their shiny new 4x4s and gleaming caravans, occupying at least 40 spaces in the council Pay and Display car park, for periods of several days.

No tickets issued, no charges whatsoever, for the use of spaces which would cost ordinary citizens substantial sums for each space.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - brum

Some advice to the OP

this forum is no place to seek advice of any sorts, its full of OAPs full of self importance who regard themselves as experts in all things and who love to play god/judge/police.

You only enter into a civil contract when there is recorded acknowledgement of such contract by both sides, that involves usually a signature, a verbal conversation, or some other action such as pushing a button under a sign that say I agree to this contract and accepting a ticket at a barrier. I drive/walk past millions of signs and they do not obligate me to do anything. Only those signs that the government deem legal notices such as those found in the highway code.

You need to visit a proper site (maybe peppipoo) and ingnore anything these private firms throw at you. Dont enter into correspondence or talk to them as they might construe that as an agreement. They will go away.

A civil dispute is not "breaking the law" and ridiculous examples of parking in someones drive or whatever have no merit - but then this is what I expect from some of the members who live here.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - 2.0Tsi
Here here Brum, well said.

I cannot fathom out some of the posters on here who are as god rightously perfect in the way they drive.

The thing is you can guarantee every single motoring forum has one, and they also tend not to know when to give it a rest from atop their moral high ground !

Motoring muppetry ;)
parking charge from The Range - not paying! - skidpan

his forum is no place to seek advice of any sorts, its full of OAPs full of self importance who regard themselves as experts in all things and who love to play god/judge/police.

If Brum had had the inteligence to read an earlier post of mine he would have spotted that I talked about the office car park at work. That obviously means I am not an OAP.

I cannot fathom out some of the posters on here who are as god rightously perfect in the way they drive

Again, where did I ever say I was perfect. I simply live on a planet where there are rules and iof you ignore those rules there tend to be consequences. If you break those rules you have to accept that there will be a price to pay.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - bananastand

Skid you have consistently confused parking on private land and "breaking the law". I'm still not sure you've got the position fully clear in your mind.

I've done a bit of research and Common Law states that any compensation must be proprtionate to the losses incurred. The car park was a third full, I was there for under two hours, therefore the loss was zero. I am writing to Care Parking today.

With acknowledgements to moneysavingexpert.

Have a nice day at the call centre Skid.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - bananastand

Dear Sirs

I am writing to reject your invoice and will not be paying.

The vehicle was parked for a maximum of approximately one hour. If it is your operative's contention that I parked for over two hours, I would remind you that perjury in UK courts carries very severe penalties.

The notice was positioned neatly over the tax disc so that I wouldn't notice it. The ploy worked. If I had I would have gone straight into the store to complain. I also wonder if your operatives were keeping a watch on the car. If I had gone into The Range, would the notice have been removed before I came out again? I suspect so, but we will never know. I wonder how The Range would react to angry customers returning purchases they had made five minutes previously, because they've been given one of these notices?

I am no longer a regular customer of The Range as I don't want to waste time countering these unscrupulous tactics.

Under Common Law, any penalty must reflect the losses incurred by the issuer of the penalty. The car park was approximately one third full, so I did not deprive the store of custom. I was parked for much less than the two hour limit. Therefore there were no losses. If you still consider that I have broken the terms of the contract, then the contract is unfair and the charge wildly disproportionate.

I now consider this correspondence closed.

Yours

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - RickyBoy

Oooh, I like that. As Metallica used to say '**** 'em all!'

Cut, pasted & archived for future use, then again I...

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - cilvilservant

Skidpan

As you mentioned parking in driveways earlier, what price would there be to pay if I parked in your driveway?

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - bananastand

By the way chaps, the sticky envelope thing said "it is an offence for any person other than the driver to remove this notice". Is that true? Remember this is on private land. Ta.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - bananastand

On moneysavingexpert there is a blizzard of information about this subject, my head is spinning. There seems to be a lot of people saying don't identify the driver. Hmmm.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - jacks

On moneysavingexpert there is a blizzard of information about this subject, my head is spinning. There seems to be a lot of people saying don't identify the driver. Hmmm.

According to HJ, If the car parking enforcement company are members of the BPA they can request - from your number plate - the registered keepers details from DVLA.

If they are not BPA members they can't (and can't therefore persue you), so before you send the letter and identify yourself, check if they are BPA members.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - Bromptonaut

According to HJ, If the car parking enforcement company are members of the BPA they can request - from your number plate - the registered keepers details from DVLA.

If they are not BPA members they can't (and can't therefore persue you), so before you send the letter and identify yourself, check if they are BPA members.

I think it's a bit more complicated then that.

Anybody can get RK details provided they can show cause and they pay the requisite fee. Cause obviously includes alleged damage but also extends to vehicles left on private land; tresspassers for want of a better analogy.

What 'approved' users like BPA members have is on line access subject to an agreement with DVLA covering proper use, Data Protection etc.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - daveyjp

Of course it's not true and such statements fly right in the face of all guidance for private parking companies., They are after your money, imitating authority is the only way they can do it.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - skidpan

Have a nice day at the call centre Skid.

I am way too intelligent to be working at a call centre unlike most of the sad muppets who inhabit this forum.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - bananastand

I've started a thread on moneysavingexpert and thankfully that site doesn't have too many "well you shouldn't have broken the rules should you" types.

The advice seems to be to wait for the RK letter to come in, then appeal.

I can't remember if i mentioned this in a previous post, but having looked at the signs again (The Range, St Helens) it says that anyone parking there must not leave the site! So that's what my ticket is for!

I had a stand up row with the manager too, in front of a load of customers.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - bananastand

Hey Jacks, yes they are members. "Care Parking". Such a nice fluffy friendly name.

I've decided against that letter I put on here before!!

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - skidpan

I can't remember if i mentioned this in a previous post, but having looked at the signs again (The Range, St Helens) it says that anyone parking there must not leave the site! So that's what my ticket is for!

So now you admit you have broken the T & C's thus the ticket is justified, about time.

Pay up and accept you were wrong all the time.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - bananastand

A fault in the logic again. This sign, which incidentally has been clipped on top of the old sign, says that people parking there must not leave the site. So of course you can't buy a packet of sandwich bags and then spend the day in work. But what about if you nip to the sweet shop over the road? What if you just step over the boundary and step back in again? Doesn't make sense.

I'll let y'all know how it goes. Meanwhile here's my thread on MSE, which thankfully doesn't have so many sociopaths on it.

forums.moneysavingexpert.com/showthread.php?p=6540...5

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - skidpan

A fault in the logic again

What is the problem with my logic. Surely the wording saying you must not leave site is easy enough to understand. What different interpretations can there be on that. The only negotiable aspect could be the definition of the site boundary and that is normally well defined by footpaths etc.

Misleading and offensive remarks on this thread - B(P)arking Mad

bananastand aka spencer999 has alerted the MSE forum on motoring advice to the profoundly misleading comments and "advice" given here by ill-informed people with no clear understanding of the law on parking.

To be clear, parking on a private retail park is NOT the same as parking in the street. Parking the street is covered by somethign that several people on here don't seem to understand - legislation. This means the offence is codified in law, and there are legal controls over breaking these laws, and how they are deal with.

So the remark from "skidpan" (who seems seriously out of order) about

Law Abiding Citizens

&

cannot be bothered to park legally

are particlarly daft and badly informed. Take no notice of such stupid remarks.

Retail parks, and most other private land, is not covered by legislation. This means for a start there is NO OFFENCE and whatever the person is doing it's not going to be FINED. Parking companies often rely on scamming people for minor or silly things, that are not anything like a real loss, and it is this that the OP is unhappy about.

So to be clear, for example:

parking for a few minutes more than the arbitary time the other party has "set" on an unreadable notice is unreasonable.

leaving the site, while otherwise using the retailers on site is not an "offence"

If you want to have an clear, honest and accurate apprasial of the situatuon, especailly the WINS at POPLA and in court over these issues, rather than repeat myself endlessly here against the noise of the inevitable backlash from the rathter foolish commentators here, can I invite you to search on line for

Money Saving Expert Forums - Motoring Forum

And

Parking Prankster

Here you will get accurate information without any spleen and vindictivness.

Edited by B(P)arking Mad on 01/05/2014 at 15:59

Misleading and offensive remarks on this thread - brum

"By entering this store, you must spend at least £20 otherwise you will be fined £100" - is that reasonable?

My local in town Tesco have removed the silly NPR cameras - whoever ran those (if anyone actually did) has lost his contract - now there are badly printed signs (inkjet - not good for outdoor signage)

"This carpark is for the use of customers only. Be prepared to be checked by our car park attendant. WHEEL CLAMPING IN PROGRESS."

Firstly - thats ok - I'm a customer - look heres my clubcard - oh it didnt say I had to go in or buy something, and what if I'm just browsing or returning that faulty tablet you sold me yesterday?

And didnt they know WHEEL CLAMPLING IS ILLEGAL (in the the sense that the police will take notice)

Ignore the ticket.

Misleading and offensive remarks on this thread - 2.0Tsi
Skid pan is one of these motoring Forum posters who would tell you that your car is not white but is in fact a lighter shade of grey.

Most of the posters on this topic can see who/what/why the OP was asking for and his reasoning and have given him some answers.......unlike one who is just a bitter troll who now has went too far down the road to do a U-turn as no doubt he would say its 'an offence' to admit a stupid point of view !

To the OP I'm glad you got 'good' and helpful advice elsewhere, rather than being trolled and provoked.
Misleading and offensive remarks on this thread - thunderbird

In car parks all over the UK people pay for a ticket and/or follow the T & C's on display. It appears to me we are now being advised that there is no need to pay and if we get a ticket to simply ignore it as its not enforcable and the company will not try and collect the fine.

First thing, are the people giving this advice prepared to offer a garantee that they will cover all costs should the car park owner persue the car owner.

Secondly, if they are so sure about this advice why is it not displayed just as prominently as the car parking T & C's, perhaps in local newspaper adverts.

Personally I feel this thread has gone on long enough. Poster who have the correct view that you should pay and follow the T & C's are called TROLLS and the companies who collect the fines are called SCUM. In my world its the people who are encouraging others to ignore the T & C's and not pay who are the SCUM and TROLLS.

Earlier in the post Jamie said that he only considers double yellow lines to be advisory, I truely hope that was just a provovcative comment (the type he is well known for) and not his real world view.

Edited by thunderbird on 02/05/2014 at 09:57

Misleading and offensive remarks on this thread - RickyBoy

...and when I said 'Ditto' that quite obviously referred to only the 'I rarely pay for parking' phrase, not the yellow line stuff - just saying, like...

...for what it's worth/in my humble, personal, unique to me opinion, blah, blah, blah, my basic philosophy in life is WIN SOME/LOSE SOME!

Over the years I've won a good number but also lost a few. Take it on the chin and move on. If you're out of pocket one week endeavour to make up the difference from another source the next (legitimately of course) by haggling down the premium on your next renewal. At the end of the day/week/month/year if everything pretty much balances out – result?

Anyway, enough of this nonsense, I've got a shed to paint – oh, erm, that was the other week!

Have a good bank holiday all as the weather seems fair(ish) set unless, of course, you live in ******** and be mindful where you park those motors!!!

RB

Misleading and offensive remarks on this thread - 72 dudes

Ooh, I've just invented a new rule!

Skidpan must not reply to this post. My terms and conditions are that if he does, he must pay me £100.

Mwah ha ha

Misleading and offensive remarks on this thread - skidpan

Ooh, I've just invented a new rule!

Skidpan must not reply to this post. My terms and conditions are that if he does, he must pay me £100.

Mwah ha ha

I have not replied to this thread for almost 24 hours. Its a waste of time with such complete muppets that inhabit this type of post.

As far as I am aware its the Forum owners who create rules and not deadheads like you.

Edited by Avant on 02/05/2014 at 12:58

Misleading and offensive remarks on this thread - RickyBoy

Heh – let's cull this thread NOW!!!

So, that Clarkson fella and his motormouth – any thoughts?...

Misleading and offensive remarks on this thread - cilvilservant

Skidpan

I'm sure you have just commited an offence with your last post.

Misleading and offensive remarks on this thread - daveyjp

Thunderbird

Just as you believe we should abide by the rules on a board in a car park and suffer the consequences if we don't, those giving out invoices also have rules to abide to and more importantly laws of the land. It has been shown time and time again that they aren't following these rules, they are breaking the law so the invoice is not valid.

No one is advising anyone not to pay in a P&D car park. If you don't you are liable for the charge you should have paid.

There is no need to pay the invoice.

The advice is NOT to ignore.

The advice is to appeal through a well established alternative dispute resolution process (POPLA) - with the right argument, which is well publicised on websites, you will win and the charge will be dropped.

There are people out there willing to appeal on your behalf and if they lose they pay the charge.

parking charge from The Range - not paying! - Avant

End ot thread. It's descended to insults and is no longer serving any useful purpose.

Parking charges/ penalties are something of a legal minefield and should be left to the experts.