Scoop Road Test: Smart Roadster | Motoring discussion | Back Room Forum

Fri 31 Jan 2003 13:44

Scoop Road Test: Smart Roadster - Dan J

Well done for getting this up so quick HJ.

I read the article with interest but can't help but think that MCC have missed what could've been a superb opportunity with this car.

It's extremely pretty and will be one of the cars that defines the new generation of small sports cars. However they have overpriced it IMHO. Given the choice between this and Ford's well marketed Streetka I'd have no hesitation where I'd send my money. I had expected the Roadster to undercut the Streetka by a grand or two to maintain competetiveness but dearer? It also has the larger engine and increased loadspace on the Ford to compete with. No competition.

Also who in their right mind would want one of these in bottom spec 60bhp format? You'll get the set of people who love to jump on this bandwagon much as they did screaming to get their hands on LHD Beetles but a driver's car this ain't.

I had been really excited about this car and thought it might well appear on my "to investigate" list for when I replace my Vectra next year but after reading your article I very much doubt it.

I see it as a "hairdressers" car and one that will not be taken seriously - if they'd have thought this through more carefully, I think it would've made a much bigger impact than it will do. 14.5k for the RHD roadster? I'll save 6 grand more and look at the RX8 thanks very much!!

Still, am always ready to be proved wrong :)

Reply | Report as offensive | Link

Fri 31 Jan 2003 14:06

Scoop Road Test: Smart Roadster - Martin Wall

Indeed - the WhatCar? website lists what 'great value' the car is - what planet are these guys on?!!

Reply | Report as offensive | Link

Related questions

Unwarranted attention?

I have recently been quoted £230 by BMW, to change the oil on my 123d M Sport Coupe. This is the first service as indicated by the on board computer. A colleague put me in touch with a BMW trained specialist...

Pole fault

I have a 2006 VW Polo Sport 1.9TDI so it is now 4 years old and has done 18,000 miles. It is about to go in for its annual service and MOT and the garage is recommending changing the cambelt. Is this really...

Diesenfranchised

Your recent e-mail from a Volvo V70 owner in Eccles reinforces my belief that Volvo franchised dealers lack "imagination". I have owned from virtually new a 1999 XC70 which has done over 200,000 miles...

Long strife servicing

My Golf Plus 2.0 TDI Sport is now a year old and the Service Indicator counted down to "Service in 200 miles" then said "Service Now", although the service sticker on the B pillar indicated variable servicing...

Ask Honest John

Sell Your Car

Real MPG

Fuel Calculator