Does my Nissan X-Trail really need three new valves?

I have a Nissan 2003 X-Trail 2.2 DCI Sport. Recently it broke down, making a very nasty mechanical noise from the engine. The car would not start very well and did not tick over. I could drive it at full power but it was very noisy with much black smoke from the back. I took it to a mechanic who said it sounded like the timing chain and tensioner, so he replaced it. I got a phone call later, saying they had started it and it still sounded awful. Now it needs three new valves. Would I have had full power from the car if three valves were bent?

Asked on 10 August 2010 by greggb06

Answered by Honest John
The timing chain problem has caused pistons to hit the valves, so simply replacing the timing chain did not repair the engine damage.
Similar questions
My Ford Focus 2006 1.6 Zetec 115ps has an intermittent hunting/cutting out problem. It is worse when the engine is warm, especially after a a warm start. The car will not idle and when driving along at...
I have a really serious problem with my 1997 Ford Ka. I start the engine - no problem; it starts promptly and idles itself immediately. And it runs that way fine until I touch the accelerator. When I do...
I'm experiencing the common timing chain rattle on my low millage (36,000) 6 year old Seat Ibiza 1.2 TSI engine. I've been quoted £400 for replacement at an independent garage. Is it worth having the chain...