MX5 vs GT86 - Which is best?

I am thinking of buying a sports car. What is your view on the Mazda MX-5 (2.0-litre not the 1.5) and Toyota GT86. Cost wise there is not much difference between the two. Is the GT86 a real four-seater (kids in the back)? Do you have any further info on the Tiaga top version of MX5 due in the winters?

Asked on 15 June 2016 by Vignesh

Answered by Honest John
What these offer is fantastic handling. But the problem with all of them is lack of torque at low revs, to the extent you can find yourself needing 4th for slight motorway inclines. As long as you're happy with having to change down when you wouldn't normally expect to, fine. A turbo would overcome this, but that wasn't the point of the design. The MX5 based FIAT Spider does, in fact, have a turbo and, despite a mere 1.4 litre capacity, actually has more mid-range torque than the MX5 2.0 litre. I remember the Mk II MX5 1.6 that came with a measly 88hp and feeling stupid not even having the power to overtake.
Similar questions
I currently own a 2016 Mazda MX5 1.5. If I change it, what are the best options for a sports/roadster type under £25,000?
I'm thinking of trading in my Volkswagen Scirocco soon and am considering what to get next. The shortlist is another Scirocco, Toyota GT86, BMW 2 Series coupe, or Audi TT. The budget is £30k or so. Which...
I received an unexpected text from my Porsche dealer asking if they could buy my 2006 34,800 mile Cayman. I responded and apparently they've had a run on used sales and are in need of stock, with a high...
Related models
Hugely enjoyable and involving to drive. Great amounts of grip and superb handling. Free-revving 2.0-litre non-turbo engine produces 200PS. Low rev torque improves for 2017 MY.
Excellent handling makes it fun to drive. 1.5-litre model works very well on uneven UK roads. 2.0 as quick as many drivers would ever want. Well-equipped for the money.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer