Should I buy a Mercedes-Benz E220 CDI Avantgarde or a BMW 520d SE Touring?

I am now retired and in the fortunate position of being able to afford one last new decent car. Our priorities are comfort and driving enjoyment. The car must be diesel (for economy) and estate with an automatic gearbox. I cannot make a decision between a Mercedes-Benz E220 CDI Avantgarde and the new BMW 520d SE Touring.

Asked on 25 July 2010 by Yorkydownsouth

Answered by Honest John
The new E-Class estate is the best looking of the new Es. Mercedes-Benz has been having some trouble with its piezo injectors, a percentage of which are coming through of insufficiently fine quality. The BMW F10 is an excellent car. Can't say for the 520, but the 530d saloon is video tested on this site.
Similar questions
I have been looking at buying a 2010 ex-demonstrator Mercedes-Benz E250 CDI or a 2010 ex-demonstrator Jaguar XF 3.00 D Luxury. The latter gets a good write-up, but I fear Jaguar's residuals. The Mercedes-Benz...
I am looking to replace our 57-plate Mercedes-Benz in the next six months. I would like a comfortable and economical estate which is also an enjoyable drive. We have been slightly disappointed with the...
Would appreciate some comment and guidance as to how best to spend up to £15,000 on a second-hand 'luxury' saloon. I only travel around 6000 miles annually, mostly short journeys with occasional 200 -...
Related models
Brilliant ride and handling, powerful and efficient diesel engines, upmarket interior, very safe, lots on the used market.
Distinctive and sharp looks. Excellent CDI diesels. Good motorway cruiser. Very comfortable and refined. Feels very well built.

Ask Honest John

Value my car