Would you choose the 2008 Toyota Avensis, 2007 Volkswagen Golf or 2007 Volkswagen Passat?

I drive about 20,000 miles each year including about three trips to France, during which time I tow a light caravan for no more than three weeks. I look for economical, reliable and comfortable motoring. For the same price, i.e. about £11,000, I can get a 2008 Toyota Avensis Estate D4D T3X, a 2007 Volkswagen Golf 1.9SE TDI Estate, or a 2007 Passat 1.9SE TDI Estate, all with about 30,000 miles. I carry a bike thus the need for an estate. Have you any thoughts as to which will prove the best long-term buy? I tend to keep my cars for up to five years.

Asked on 14 July 2010 by Timbo101

Answered by Honest John
I'd rate the Avensis of all of these on the basis of far fewer problems reported, though they can have a cylinder head problem. See the entries in car by car breakdown on this site.
Similar questions
I am an equine veterinary surgeon doing over 40,000 miles a year. My Saab 9.3 2.2-litre diesel has come to the end of its life at close to 300,000 miles. What do you suggest to replace it? I always buy...
I am looking to buy a 2007 Toyota Prius that has done 136,000 miles but comes with a full service by Toyota for £4700. The car is in very good condition. Are there any pitfalls of buying a high mileage...
I'm still reviewing my options regarding the purchase of a used Toyota Prius (approximately two years old) for private use and work as a 'Private Hire' taxi. Unfortunately I can't afford the current model,...
Related models
Solid car. Sophisticated multi-link suspension deliberately unstressed for long life. Quite quick T180 diesel from July 2006.
Decent handling and comfortable on the move, impressive TSI engines, massive improvement over the previous Golf, high-economy Bluemotion models, high quality feel of interior, five-star Euro NCAP safety rating.
Spacious and comfortable. Wide range of engines. Big, boot with lockable seatbacks. Generally better from May 2008 onwards.
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car