Best used small car for £5000?

I am looking to buy a used small car for around £5000 that will last me for some years to come. I would like the best value for money and would be much more interested in reliability, fuel efficiency, low insurance costs and tax rather than features, driving experience or stylishness.

I would be very grateful if you could suggest some suitable models.

Asked on 27 November 2014 by Edward

Answered by Honest John
Another reader today had the Mitsubishi Colt on his list. A Colt 1.5 diesel would make a lot of sense. So would a previous model KIA Rio 1.5 diesel. Neither have diesel particulate filters to worry about.
Similar questions
I want to upgrade my 2006 Toyota Corrolla. I have £10,000 to spend and require a reliable, stylish and economical car that will accommodate my wife and daughter. My daily commute is 30 miles and I also...
I am looking for a petrol automatic five-door hatchback that is not a crossover, too large or firm riding. The car must be comfortable, well-equipped, reasonably economical, reliable and ULEZ-compliant. Are...
What are the best used cars for fuel economy for less than £20,000?
Related models
Affordable to run, Ralliart version is great fun to drive, feels robust and reliable.