What should I replace my A5 Sportback with?

As my Audi A5 Sportback reaches five years old, I am thinking about a replacement before big repair bills start appearing. I have done 26,000 miles (trouble free) and want something with similar 180PS performance.

What would you recommend for a quiet ride. I do most of my motoring about town with a few 500 mile round trips to visit family. I have driven Audis for my last four cars and enjoyed the ride and handling. Are there any good alternatives?

Asked on 26 September 2014 by ibp10

Answered by Honest John
Yes, it is time to move on. The problem is that we're on the cusp of a lot of new model and engine developments in the same class: New Jaguar XE with Ingenium 2.0 litre petrol engines, new Volvos with various single and twin turbo 2.0 litre Volvo engines, BMW engines under continuous development.

You could step back a notch and go for a Mazda 6 that is better than and A5 and cheaper, but doesn't have the status. Or consider a BMW 3-Series Gran Turismo, or 4-Series GT, or 4-Series coupe, remembering that the deeper the profile of your tyres the more comfortable the car is going to be, so don't go for 19 or 20-inch wheels.
Similar questions
I do approximately 21,000 miles a year, which includes a two hour drive to work. So, as you might imagine, I want to buy a comfortable car as my current Peugeot RCZ is too uncomfortable for my back. What...
I have two year old Mercedes-Benz C-Class estate that I wish to replace. I have up to £40,000 to spend, but the car must have a smooth ride and lots of space, as my wife is disabled. Can you offer any...
I have a six year old Subaru Forester and a 13 year old Volkswagen Passat saloon. I intend to keep the Subaru and change the Passat. Can you recommend a replacement car that would be good for long journeys?...
Related models
Svelte coupe looks with large hatchback practicality. Plenty of space and headroom in the back. Low emissions from 2.0 TDI 170.
Nimble and agile handling. Spacious cabin is very well made. Huge improvements to refinement and steering from October 2016.
Four-door with hatchback practicality. Electric tailgate as standard. Available with xDrive four-wheel drive. Impressive ride quality.