Is £400 a reasonable price to repair the sills on my 1996 Ford Escort?

I run a 1996 Ford Escort Ghia 1.8i Cabriolet. It's done 73,000 miles and is in excellent condition. Recently, I took it to a local garage for its MoT. I was told my car needed new sills to pass and I was given a verbal quote of £300 + VAT (this was said to be from the third-party body shop to which the garage contracts its repairs). I left the car to be repaired and collected it four days later. Without reference to me, the garage paid the bodyshop on my behalf then told me that the cost was actually £400 + VAT - so another £120 is now due. I queried the invoice, reiterating the original verbal quotation. I wonder if, being female, I’m being treated as a soft touch. Irrespective of the disputed quote, is £300 + VAT reasonable and £400 + VAT excessive? What legal redress do I have, if any? Can I complain to a professional standards body? Regrettably, after two decades, this garage will never again get any business from me.

Asked on 7 September 2013 by JJ, Louth

Answered by Honest John
Actually, £400 + VAT is reasonable for cutting out the old rusted sills, welding any further rust that was found, welding on new outer sills and painting. No one knows how expensive a job like this will be until they take the old sills off and see the true extent of the corrosion.
Similar questions
The email regarding paint problems following bonnet repairs reminded me of problems I had about thirty years ago when I was unfortunate enough to own a BL Princess. After about 12 months, pit marks appeared...
I have a 58-reg Toyota Avensis and I found rust in a couple of areas. Toyota have agreed to replace all four doors. The areas round the doors will be sprayed to blend the colour in. What is the likelihood...
I have recently noticed fairly significant rust on three of the four wheel arches and around the boot lock. Firstly, have I got a chance of getting this fixed by MB. It is a 52 plate and had its last...
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer