What caused the fuel filters on my Skoda Superb Estate diesel to repeatedly clog up?

Over the past few months my Skoda Superb Estate has been performing worse and worse from cold starts, with what appeared to be misfires or fuel starvation until it had begun to warm up. At its third variable service earlier this year, I mentioned this matter to the Skoda dealership but they were not able to reproduce the problem, since they never started the car from cold. This major service included many extra items and cost me over £800.

As part of the service the fuel filter was changed, and I can see part number 3C0127434 on the itemised bill of work. However, last week the general clatter from a cold start was so bad that I booked the car in for investigative work at a different Skoda dealership, and they have determined fuel contamination, requiring a full system flush and another new filter. This second garage have said that the existing filter is blocked with an oily-greasy substance, the diesel in the tank "smells odd", and that the whole repair will cost around £350, plus £49 for the initial diagnosis work.

Asked on 13 July 2013 by DE, via email

Answered by Honest John
Seems that all that has happened here is that one dealer has fitted a new fuel filter without investigating why it clogged, but, faced with the fact that the filter clogged again, the second dealer did a more thorough job. At some time you must have filled with contaminated fuel, but, since you don't know when, it's impossible to hold anyone to blame.
Similar questions
My 20,000 mile Grand C-Max 1.6TDCI, after several transient episodes, recently went into permanent 'limp home' mode. The dealer reported that the fault was due to a partially blocked fuel filter, and...
The night before last I drove, with a friend, to a meeting about 10 miles away in my recently-purchased Citroen 2008 C5 2.0 HDI 138 Automatic, 61,000 miles on the clock. Three hours later, when I switched...
Can someone offer advice about my Peugeot 306TD? The car starts first time and runs well, with no misfiring or whistles, but there is no turbo effect whatsoever. When you floor the throttle the motor gradually...
Related models
Huge interior and load space. More legroom in the back than a Mercedes-Benz S-Class. Clever touches throughout. Well specified as standard and great value for money.