Do some fuel pumps dispense less fuel than they say?

I recently filled my car with petrol, and as I replaced the pump noticed the display read 46.5 litres. I was sure my tank only holds 45 and it hadn't been empty, but couldn't prove it so paid and left. The manual later confirmed my car has a 45 litre tank and the low fuel light comes on with seven litres remaining, so I had put in 38 litres and been overcharged by about £11.50. I went back to the garage with my receipt and manual, and they were happy to refund me, but convinced I had simply been charged for the wrong pump. I explained that this was not possible as I had first noticed the error on the pump itself, and asked that they have it checked for a fault, but don't know whether they did. I don't know whether this is a common problem, but thought it might be worth a warning to other readers.

Asked on 6 April 2013 by HW, Wymondham, Norfolk

Answered by Honest John
Second report of this in a week. It may be that some pumps are under-dispensing. Report to Trading Standards who should still have their old 'Weights and Measures Department' equipment for testing.
Similar questions
Should I buy a 2017 Lexus which has five Lexus dealer services in the record although there's a gap of 3 years? The car is being sold by a Lexus dealer.
I recently bought a used 2017 Mercedes GLC and I noticed that the AdBlue gauge doesn’t seem to change from 3100 miles although I have driven about 500 miles since I last checked. Is this a fault or does...
My Audi Q3 diesel is 5 years old and has covered 46,000 miles. The dealer says it needs a new belt and water pump for £1300, but according to my service schedule, it isn’t due yet. I’ve had a mechanic...
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer