Why is my Mercedes-Benz so thirsty?

Three weeks ago I bought a 10-month-old Mercedes-Benz B160 auto from a Mercedes dealership with 10,000 miles on the clock. I have been depressed by the high fuel consumption. I am quite a conservative driver and don't hammer the car, but around London I'm getting 23-25mpg. MB’s figure for urban driving is 32.5mpg. On a motorway run I'm getting 34mpg but MB advertises 45.6mpg. MB’s combined figure is 39.8mpg. MB has tested the car and says everything is perfect, and admitted the engine is underpowered for such a heavy car. I'd love them to take it back but do I have any chance of this?

Asked on 17 March 2012 by CH, London SE12

Answered by Honest John
No. The 'advertised' figures are the figures that manufacturers are compelled by EC law to provide and tell you only the results of the EC lab tests. They do not represent what you can realistically expect. For that you need to visit www.honestjohn.co.uk/realmpg.
Similar questions
My 2010 Honda Jazz 1.4 EX gives strange fuel consumption results. I filled it to the brim, looked at the computer and it said it could do 490 miles until next fill. I drove approximately 300 miles, at...
I have a 2014 Porsche Macan 3.0-litre diesel, bought new. It recorded 42mpg or better on a long run and 39mpg average on short urban runs. Porsche wrote asking for the car to have a software update for...
BMW quote up to 148mpg, battery mileage up to 25 miles for my BMW 330e. I can only attain 58 mpg and battery range between 6.8 and 12 miles. I feel I have been misled badly by BMW. I would value your opinion...
Related models
Raised driving position, lots of interior room, decent diesel engines, good ride quality on smaller wheels.