Best small car for long-term ownership?

My wife has been running a Y-reg 1.0-litre petrol Yaris since new, and has now clocked up over 120k miles at over 50mpg, mostly commuting 15 miles each way into Leeds with the occasional longer journey. It is now starting to show its years and we are looking at a replacement. We will probably buy new or nearly new, and will aim to keep the car for at least 10 years.

Do you think we should concentrate only on Korean or Japanese makes? Should we go for the long-term economy of diesel, or the long-term reliability of petrol?

As an aside, we recently had to replace the rear wheel bearings and the Toyota parts were £250 per side, plus fitting at our local garage! They would only sell the complete hub, including ABS hardware. Even pattern parts would have cost over £500 to fit. In the end, we went for the bearings off a low-mileage scrapped car...

Asked on 14 December 2012 by YorkshireJumbo

Answered by Honest John
Stick to Toyota or to Honda. Even out of warranty these two companies look after carbuyers best.
Dear Honest John,

Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
    Select a few terms below
Similar questions
On 23 November, I bought a 61-plate (registered Feb 2012) Volkswagen Golf 1.2 TSI 85 S five-door for £9629 from a dealer. The salesman told my wife and I that the car was previously registered to Volkswagen,...
The manufacturer's warranty on my 2008 1.6 petrol Ford Focus ends in a few months. It's got roughly 30,000 miles on the clock. As I see it I can trade it in or keep it and run it into the ground. Problem...
Her indoors wants to change our 2003 A3 TDI Quattro for either an Audi A4 Avant, Volkswagen Tiguan or a Golf Estate. Please can you let us know how much we would expect for trade in on our Audi? It has...