Peugeot 508 or VW Passat?

I have two options: new 508 SW 2.0 HDi 163 automatic or new Passat 2.0 TDi estate DSG/

Do you have any thoughts as to which is the better choice?

It seems as though the Peugeot is a more fun car to drive, and the looks are attractive.

However the Passat has been around for a long time and so is "proven".

I've always liked Peugeots, however I have heard that the electrics can be problematic.

I would like to run the car for 5 years and am looking for trouble-free motoring for that length of time at least.

Asked on 6 August 2012 by nimbus

Answered by Honest John
The current Passat is vastly better than it's 2005-2011 predecessor that had a long list of problems and gets just two stars from owners in our review. DSGs can be trouble, though. The 508 163 has a torque converter auto and a more reliable engine on past performance. But I'd wait until next year's Mondeo.
Similar questions
I'm looking to buy one of the following - Volvo V60, Peugeot 508, Citroen C5, Toyota Avensis. Looking for a comfortable, reliable, safe car. I've driven German cars over the years, but hate the harsh...
I have a 90,000 mile 53 plate Nissan X-Trail with a head gasket on its way out (so I'm told). I have two small children and two small dogs and regulaly drive to Northern France from London. The replacement...
I am looking at buying a Mondeo Titanium X 2.0 TDCI 130bhp on a 58 plate - but it has 90000 miles on the clock. The car looks mint and in very good condition, and has a full Ford service history. Is the...
Related models
Neatly styled. Comfortable and easy to drive. Economical diesels.
Very comfortable and refined. Good ride quality on broken surfaces. Wide range of engines including excellent TSI petrols, BlueMotion CO2 figure now 109g/km.
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car