Buying a second 'work horse'

My husband and I love our Honda Accords but they are over 7 years old. We've moved somewhere rural and my poor Type S gets manure in the twin exhausts, punctures and scratches from pulling in all the time on single lanes, and muck from farm vehicles. With a 10 mile round trip to get milk we desperately need 2 totally reliable cars.

We've been hit badly by the public sector cuts so need to be cost conscious. We want to get one car through the NHS lease car scheme and need to find the cheapest option. - any reliable, small family car which costs under £250 a month (including 40% company car tax).

The other car will then be a real workhorse - a big, reliable car which can fit 3 kid booster seats, bikes or a sensible bike rack, kayaks on the roof, family trips to France, etc and not mind mud and close encounters with stone walls.

We would love the new Honda CRV but might not be able to afford it (max £25,000 budget). Fuel costs are also a concern and the workhorse will do many 10 mile trips a day so presumably that won't suit a diesel.

Asked on 15 May 2012 by Honda-lover

Answered by Honest John
Possibly a Nissan Qashqai 1.6DCI 130, from £20,000 with 2WD. That has fast warm technology so the DPF should be no problem, and base versions have smaller wheels with deeper profile tyres to take the bumps and potholes.
Similar questions
I need a replacement for a 2010 Skoda TDi Octavia Scout (which has been a very good car - have loved the elevated seating position which is a must in my new car). I am looking now as the Scout took over...
I currently drive a 1.5 tech run Renault Megane. We're expecting our second child and need bigger boot and more spacious interior. I also have a bad back so was looking for something higher up. Budget...
We currently have a Nissan Qashqai, but are looking for a car with a more practical boot space. We do a lot of mountain biking and a lot of camping so often load the boot up with mountain bikes and camping...
Related models
Very comfortable front seats with good ride. Feels well built. Strong Renault sourced dCi diesels. Elevated driving position and good visibility.