Switching from a MINI to an Audi A2

I currently drive a 54 plate Mini Cooper (Black) top spec with chilli pack (59000 miles with full BMW service history).

Even though it is reliable, and the service intervals are good, it is costing me a fortune to run - Mainly new tyres (17" wheels), and petrol (Average around 33-34 mpg).

I am thinking of trading it in for a 54 plate Audi A2 (only 28000 miles) 1.4 petrol, which is on the market for just below 5k. The low miles and rust-proof body appeal to me. Do you think that this is a wise decision? and how much do you think I should command for my MINI price wise?

Asked on 23 April 2012 by LukeTee

Answered by Honest John

Not a good idea. Because although the A2 is a minor classic, parts (especially body parts) are very expensive and there are only a few places capable of fixing them. On top of that the 1.4 petrol engine in it is a truly lousy engine. One of VAG's worst ever.

Tags: buying part exchange used cars

Dear Honest John,

Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:

Similar questions

Best way to sell a 54 plate Mondeo

A friend is part exchanging a 54 plate Mondeo Zetec 2.0 (petrol) for a new Focus 1.0. He has been offered £700 in the p/e deal. It has FSH, 104k miles, everything works and it is in good condition. Should...

Buying a used car but my part-ex has been damaged

I made a verbal agreement with my local VW dealer to purchase a used Polo with mats and Autoglym included for free in the negotiation. He offered me £400 for my X reg Ford Fiesta which I told him had dodgy...

Exchanging a Chevrolet Matiz for a Citroen Berlingo?

What is my Matiz worth in part exchange? It's got FSH and will need new tyres and exhaust looking at soon (mentioned on MOT at beg Jan 2012). It's got a couple of scratches to interior but is clean,...