Should I contest a parking charge we received after breaking down at a motorway services?

I have been issued with a charge of £80 by CP Plus for overstaying my welcome at Forton services on the M6 by three hours eight minutes. In fact, we had broken down (or at least the vehicle was undrivable) due to a burst heater pipe, resulting in a total loss of coolant. When the warning message was displayed we were only a couple of miles from the services, so I took the risk of continuing to this safe haven rather than risk my family's safety on the motorway hard shoulder. We parked in the lorry section, which had plenty of space throughout the period in which we were stranded. The AA took over two hours to respond, but the repairman was able to provide a temporary fix so we could complete our journey to Scotland. Looking at other cases on your website, do you think I should offer a small fee in compensation, or do you, like me think this is totally unjustified? I intend to send a copy of the AA receipt and a letter explaining the situation and no money.

Asked on 15 September 2011 by JS, via email

Answered by Honest John
That is outrageous. You should refuse to pay on the grounds you had broken down and had no alternative. Tell them that if they take you to court you will robustly defend yourself and also that I will take steps to publicise this outrage. (JS did exactly that and received a reply stating "no further action" would be taken.)

It’s worth mentioning that the British Parking Association is now running a pilot appeals scheme here: www.parkingforum.co.uk/adjudication_pilot / It states, “This pilot is designed to test the principles behind formalising such a service and may form the basis of a statutory appeals service when the Government legislates to introduce one.”
Similar questions
Apropos of one of your recent letters topics - see this from the BBC: www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-sussex-21752893 “Motorists who were unable to leave Pease Pottage service station on the A23 on Monday...
Regarding my ‘fine’ for taking a nap in a Moto motorway rest area, following your advice, here is my response to CP Plus, which I hope will at least give you a chuckle: "Dear Sirs, Your attached request...
Last Monday our car broke down in the car park of a Welcome Break motorway services on the M5. I called out the AA and they told me it wasn't safe to drive the car. After an hour and a half under the bonnet...
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer